Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board
by Workaphobia on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @06:29PM
(#7350747)
I always assumed analogies were explicitly designed as a mechanism for testing vocabulary, not reasoning. I don't understand how analogies would have any value in testing reasoning skills. I can't imagine an analogy question that isn't either obvious or subjective.
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board
by jonnathanson on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @07:10PM
(#7350918)
The whole point of analogy problems is to test reasoning skills. Specifically, logical skills, inferences, categorization, and so forth. The vocabulary test nested within the analogy test is incidental. It creates a bivariate challenge (vocabulary + categorization), which is not necessarily an invalid test. It's just not a pure test of analogies, and it's also duplicative of the vocabulary portion of the test.
In re the value of analogies, there are some computer scientists and philosophers who believe analogy-drawing is the irreducible core of higher cognition. I'm not sure I'd go that far, but Douglas Hofstadter has come close:
http://www.amazon.com/Surfaces-Essences-Analogy-Fuel-Thinkin...
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board
by minor_nitwit on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @09:39PM
(#7351531)
why not both?
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board
by Zhenya on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @11:10PM
(#7351810)
when you test for both, its tougher to get a good measure on either.
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board
by compare on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @05:50PM
(#7350534)
I did decently the last time I took that analogies test. For me, it was all about analyzing the sub-word component meanings (i.e. each syllable and the relations of the syllables,) not just analyzing the vocabulary at the word level. Maybe I'm just strange.
One could make a strong argument for plain-English analogies, absent the $10 words. If every test taker understood most of the words, then we could test for reasoning ability on a more normalized basis.
That's not to say testing vocabulary is totally invalid. Opinions vary. But if we assume vocabulary is worth testing, then we should test it independently.