News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by 67726e on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @02:39PM (#7349283)
"Instead of teaching to the test we're going to put huge emphasis on really learning the material instead of practicing test-taking skills that won't be useful afterwards."

Now how do we get the schools to actually do that?

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by _delirium on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @02:48PM (#7349358)
Changing the incentives would be a start. If you give schools very specific metrics, and then judge them on how well they optimize those metrics for the least money, it's no surprise that they are going to... try to find the most direct way of optimizing those metrics. In fact, the ones who don't do that will be penalized!
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by eli_gottlieb on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:10AM (#7352871)
"Beware your metrics, for they will improve."
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by bradleyjg on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @02:56PM (#7349421)
Ideally you test better, such that teaching to the test is identical to teaching well. That's the theory behind the Oxbridge tutorial system. Unfortunately good tests and scalable tests seem to be mutually incompatible, and non-scalable tests incommensurable.
Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by yummyfajitas on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:03AM (#7353020)
People in discussions like this often assume that it's easy to make test scores go up without teaching the material.

Here are specific tests from some large states (the first I found via google):

http://www.nysedregents.org/Grade8/Mathematics/20100505book1...

http://www.nysedregents.org/Grade8/EnglishLanguageArts/04261...

http://www.cde.ca.gov/ta/tg/sr/documents/cstrtqmath7.pdf

How do you make scores on these specific tests go up to any significant degree without making students learn the material? Please explain the techniques in detail.

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by 67726e on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:25AM (#7353469)
Well, all of the tests are multiple choice. Switching away from the format would certainly encourage a better understanding of material. Given that the format of the 4 choices is general:

1 correct answer, 1 or 2 close but not correct answer, and 1 or 2 obviously wrong answers.

Now that format makes thing significantly easier to get the correct answer than simply presenting the problem and asking the student to solve the problem. I'd imagine some of you are thinking "Well hell, they would still need to know the formula", but they also give you formula sheets with the tests. Since they give you a list of possible answers and a list of applicable formulas, you can pretty quickly plug in some numbers and determine the correct answer. Does it still require some base understanding? Yes. But I can tell you with absolute certainty that my grades would not have been as high had I not known how to game the testing system in such a manner.

I'm only a few years removed from high school, so I cannot imagine things have changed too much, especially for the better. For reference I am from South Carolina, albeit I went to one of the more performant/richer public school systems in the state.

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by yummyfajitas on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:42AM (#7353565)
Teaching students how to get into the ballpark of the right answer and reject obviously wrong ones increases their understanding. It's an important skill and there are adults out there who embarrass themselves by failing to do it (for example http://www.buzzfeed.com/charlesclymer/5-things-more-likely-t... ).

Same thing for taking a reference work (e.g. a formula sheet, a wikipedia page) and figuring out which piece of information you need and applying it.

Remember, I'm not asking if the tests could be better. I'm asking what you do to make test scores go up without making understanding go up.

I'd be at least moderately convinced if you could even show me two teaching techniques, A and B, where A is superior for test scores but significantly inferior for understanding.

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by JoeAltmaier on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:53AM (#7353623)
I used to play rock-paper-scissors with my child. Could win every time. You could see on his face his simple logic.

You can learn to take tests - I did that for the GRE, got a 99% but hadn't ever studied 2 of the area tests I took. There's a logic to test questions, you can learn it.

There was no understanding involved, I can assure you. Just a recognition of what is considered a 'fair' question, which lets you eliminate answers that are too convoluted.

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by yummyfajitas on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:19AM (#7353752)
"I did it, it's totally possible, I'm not going to support this claim at all but I assure you it's true."

It would be far more convincing if you actually skimmed the NY Reagents test and presented a teaching strategy which you believe would raise scores but not increase understanding.

Note that if such a strategy does not exist for the NY test but does exist for every other test, then we have a solution to all the complaints about testing - use the NY test for everyone.

Re:Major Changes in SAT Announced by College Board by jjoonathan on Wednesday March 05, 2014 @02:43PM (#7349317)
You provide them with a premade test-prep curriculum that is interwoven with genuine educational videos, perhaps in a subtle way, such as providing coarse links to review material in response to incorrect answers. Then you hope that educators will either see the value in your cross-links or won't have the time to scrape your question bank and eliminate the cross-references ("condensing" the review material).

Disclaimer: I have no actual idea if this is what they're doing, I'm just saying that it could be done this way.