News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by WilliamLP on Friday July 31, 2009 @01:03PM (#734818)
That's a battle of pedantry that you lost a long time ago, and you will win it sometime after "begging the question" gets used correctly most of the time.

It's a good example of a picky use of language that adds nothing whatsoever to the understanding of the subject.

"Interval" has connotations I didn't want, namely that it's the same no matter what degree of the scale you start on. I really did mean "I, III" specifically. As far as I know, there's no term in music for that, but "chord", namely a major I chord (only without the fifth) seems to fit what I wanted to say better than "interval" to me.

Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by Goladus on Saturday August 01, 2009 @08:36AM (#736247)
Without more context it's really impossible to say whether that was a major I or not. It would be the only functional harmony in the entire pattern, so it seems unlikely it was a I. A pentatonic melody by itself doesn't infer much in the way of harmonic progression. The only reason we hear C# as tonic is because he starts there and emphasizes it with repetition and mini-cadences that are primarily rhythmic in nature. There aren't any IV or V chords available with those pitches (or iii or vii for that matter, you can imply a ii but not very well).

I would actually argue that interval actually is the most accurate term in this case. (Not that I didn't understand what was meant by the term "chord" though, and certainly wouldn't have been bothered by it)

Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by tumult on Friday July 31, 2009 @01:17PM (#734845)
why? that's the right term for it.

it's not anywhere close to a major I chord without the fifth!

never underestimate what other kinds of nerds you may encounter in the wild :]

Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by WilliamLP on Friday July 31, 2009 @02:12PM (#735012)
A major I chord without the fifth is two pitches, the first and third degrees of the major scale. That's what I meant. Why is that not anywhere close, or even not precisely the same?

I did not mean a major third interval. They could have sung the correct interval, but the wrong pitches. For what I did mean, I do insist that in the limited terminology of music, chord is a better fit because it implies the pitch where interval doesn't.

This necessitates terms like "Power Chord". Pedants are going to say this is wrong. (And oh yeah a Koala Bear isn't really a Bear either.) But it does get around a limitation of the language.

Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by alextp on Friday July 31, 2009 @01:34PM (#734900)
Technically it can be a major I chord even without the tonic (listen to some schoenberg, he likes to do this), it is just difficult to get right.
Re:Bobby McFerrin Demonstrates the Power of the Pentatonic S... by Goladus on Saturday August 01, 2009 @08:39AM (#736250)
The fifth is hardly essential to achieve the sound of a major I chord. Fifths are omitted all the time in classical music to avoid parallel voice-leading.