When you put up a wireless network in your apartment, your intention to make it public is a lot less clear. You are putting it in public, so the argument for opt-out is at least coherent. But I don't buy it because it's clearly not most peoples' intention.
Though it seems unintuitive Not broadcasting your SSID is actually less secure than broadcasting it.
Those truly worried about privacy never use wireless transmission directly, instead using a VPN (only allowing the VPN wrapped traffic go out over the air) and set their own APs to block any traffic that isn't to/from the VPN end-point(s).
They are mapping public WiFi APs, public data, it's well within their right and that of other to do so. Offering an opt-out is just going over and beyond to appease the stubbornly misinformed.
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/may/15/google-adm...
http://searchengineland.com/its-official-google-settles-wisp...
And since when is publicly broadcast SSIDs are anyone's private data?
It's very unfortunate that zealots and hateful people are increasingly finding a home on HN.
"Intended" is a description of your subjective mental state, not an objective quality of the broadcast.
> Are cordless phone transmissions publicly broadcast? Baby monitors? Burglar alarms? Home automation devices? Bluetooth headsets?
If they aren't encrypted, yes.
It appears "rename and opt-out" is the latest model. I'm guessing even fewer lay users will take this step.
Technically this allows Google to claim it gives people an easy way to opt out, but in practice nothing much is likely to change as those who were worried about privacy were probably not broadcasting their SSID publicly to begin with.