http://ycombinator.com/faq.html
Can we do it without moving to where you are?
Sorry, no. We tried this once, and by Demo Day that startup was way behind the rest. What we do, we have to do in person. We would not be doing a startup a favor by not making them move.
You can leave one founder at home, but the rest, including the CEO, have to live in the Bay Area during the 3 month funding cycle.
I am, however, -extremely- aware that I Am Not Your Target Market and that the story-oriented style can work perfectly well. But if the video is going to aim for a marcomms style then it'd be nice if you built out the explanation stuff a bit more. And made it work with ctrl+click rather than being javascript silliness only.
</grumpy-old-school-unix-head>
With the JS overlays -- when we launch the real website (in the next couple of months) it won't use those -- it's just a normal, click as you go, website. Also, we'll very likely split the video back into two, one for developers, one for site owners.
Get rid of sentences like "The solution xxx has been waiting for". Be humble in language, impress with the demonstration instead.
Get rid of the music or change it. It's okay in the beginning when it's hardly noticable but as "drama" builds up it becomes rather ridiculous (reminded me of a really bad McGyver episode).
Other than that I liked the video. It did a very good job at getting the point across for me in reasonable time. Many intro-screencasts suffer from being too long or too high- or low-level. I think you struck a good balance there.
I don't agree with the complaint that it should be more technical. For me it was just right to get a quick grasp on what you offer. Anything more detailed should either be in text or in a second screencast.
I second those who are saying that simply filling out the application (and especially, making the video - boiling your startup down to 1 minute is HARD) will be really rewarding.
I would recommend that you and your co-founders make a pact: if you get in to Y Combinator, you will do Y Combinator, full-time, 100% all the way. If anyone can't agree to that, then you shouldn't apply. Or maybe find a new co-founder.
If you're waiting for the perfect moment, even if there was such a thing, I'd be highly doubtful anyone would be able to identify it except in hindsight. In the end, you have to make up your mind for yourself, because you are going to be the one to live with the consequences.
That is the scenario we're facing with BitsyBox. We love every minute that we're working on it but I wanted to get some feedback from the HN community about whether we should start thinking about it as our big jump out of the corporate developer's life.
Basically right now, we go to our corporate jobs during the day, come back at night and work for four hours on it -- this can't be uncommon. We're ready to make the leap to work on this everyday / all day -- but we'd really like to have some seed funding or be ramen-profitable first.