News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by LordHumungous on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @08:44PM (#7344688)
When haven't things been going wrong with democracy? Whether it's the 1800's France, 1910's Russia, 1930's Europe, 1960's South America, 1990's Russia, or 2014 Ukraine, Egypt, and Syria, creating and maintaining a functioning democracy has always been hard work that is prone to failure. I suspect it will always be that way. And yet, (paraphasing Churchill), the fragile and difficult democratic system is better than any of the utopian non-democratic schemes that have been devised.
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by jseliger on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @08:48PM (#7344701)
Great comment.

I would add that to some extent the current crop of strongmen have figured out some ways of suppressing democracy more quietly than strongmen of old; Putin, for example, cloaks repression in bureaucracy.

Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by gooble_flop on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:14PM (#7344813)
> democratic system is better than any of the utopian non-democratic schemes

Those aren't the only two choices though.

Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by ekianjo on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:17PM (#7344830)
Exactly. Instead of giving a binary choice, there are other ways a country could be run. Churchill was from another era.

EDIT: Besides, Churchill was only a proponent of democracy when it was going HIS way. We have now seen communication cables between FDR and Churchill during WWII, where Churchill implored FDR to go to war against the will of the US Congress. You can't have it both ways.

Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by saraid216 on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @10:06PM (#7344999)
That doesn't surprise me. Churchill is not someone I'd look to for guidance on political governance. He's internationally recognized and respected because he was a war leader. That's the beginning and end of his qualifications.
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by ekianjo on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @10:40PM (#7345127)
I recommend the book Pearl Harbor: the Seeds and Fruits of Infamy for anyone who wants to know more (the book is quite neutral despite its title). Free PDF here: http://library.mises.org/books/Percy%20L%20Greaves,%20Jr/Pea...
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by fiatmoney on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:54PM (#7344952)
Wait, all of your examples are examples of mass violence being unleashed as a result of a conversion from an already existing non-democratic, non-utopian government to a democratic form of government (which incidentally often has has explicitly utopian goals). Your proper decision point isn't "Do I choose liberal democracy or fascism"; it's "given I live in Wilhelmine Germany, do I start a revolution to elect some Nazis".
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by Sniffnoy on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:19PM (#7344836)
That have been tried. That it's better than anything else that's been devised is far from clear.
Re:What’s gone wrong with democracy? by saraid216 on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:41PM (#7344897)
I actually disagree. (And I disagree with Churchill.)

Let's assume that we agree that liberalism is a good thing. We can hash out what "liberalism" actually means, if you like. I'm willing to be flexible on the definition. Given that assumption, let's sketch out a governmental form and argue about feasibility.

I suspect that, unless we go very far afield from mainstream concepts of liberalism, we'll arrive at something approximating democracy very closely, differing mostly in that it'll be overly idealistic.

Anyone up for playing this game?