News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument by rayiner on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:08PM (#7343150)
There's absolutely nothing Rube Goldbergian about the business model. Broadcasters generally have a right to control the distribution of their content, with the exception that in return for being able to use the airwaves, they must allow people to receive over the air television freely. That's the bargain. It's a clearly defined benefit coupled to a clearly defined obligation. Obviously, the broadcasters have a legitimate interest in not wanting companies like Aereo to game that loophole for their own profit. The public mandate isn't implicated at all. Nobody is talking about cutting off conventional over the air TV. Streaming service like Aereo was never part of that bargain.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument by revelation on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:30PM (#7343319)
This is where we reach the crux of the issue at hand. The question being: what is special about airwaves? As you explain it, broadcasters must allow me to receive their over the air content freely, but when I receive the same content from a 3rd party that took it from the air and made it available to me over cable, internet, smoke signals.. they are illegally rebroadcasting.

So between congress establishing this bargain (where the only obvious medium for broadcasting was over-the-air) and today, where there are many ways to transmit TV, it suddenly became important over which medium I receive their content under the license granted to me by the bargain the broadcasters entered into.

This seems like an odd situation we find ourselves in, because when the FCC started giving out licenses for spectrum nobody gave any thought to other mediums; there simply were no others.

I say we end this charade, broadcasters stop transmitting over the public airwaves, we repurpose their spectrum for something useful and everybody keeps watching their favourite show on cable, as they are already doing.

Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument by rayiner on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @05:09PM (#7343559)
I quite agree that there are better things to do with all that spectrum than broadcast TV. But until we do that, it seems quite obvious to me that when Congress and the broadcasters carved out the special case for over the air TV, what everyone had in mind was being able to receive signals on an antenna attached to your TV. Given that, Aereo's service is just a legal and technical hack to game that special case.