Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by diminoten on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @03:57PM
(#7343074)
Aereo isn't retransmitting to the public though, it's allowing you the ability to remotely deploy an antenna in a place where reception is good, and forwarding that signal onto you.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by kej on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:44PM
(#7343406)
It's a stretch to say they're letting me deploy an antenna. It's not like they're just an antenna colocation company where I go install it myself.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @06:19PM
(#7343949)
Suppose that you were filthy rich, owned property that included a hill, and hired people to put an antenna on your hill and run cable back to your house so you could watch TV.
Now suppose you leased a part of your hill to your neighbour so that they could do the same thing.
What's different about Aereo's model, other than the scale?
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by jsz0 on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @08:16PM
(#7344586)
> What's different about Aereo's model, other than the scale?
From a legal perspective the wording of the contract between parties matters an awful lot. A quick look at Areo's site shows they are offering something very different. If your property owner and neighbor entered a similar contract for these services I suspect they would indeed face the same legal risks. Once you become a middle man who is tuning/transcoding/transporting you fit the mold of a cable TV service provider far more than a property owner leasing land.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by maxerickson on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @06:35PM
(#7344048)
Are they somehow streaming the ATSC signal over the internet? Or are they changing the signal into some other format, storing and then sending it later?
That's at least a difference.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by icebraining on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @06:24PM
(#7343982)
An Aereo opposer could claim that leasing to your neighbor would itself be a copyright violation.
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by icebraining on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @06:17PM
(#7343930)
That's an interesting proposition. If you did have different companies doing the job - say, Aereo would rent you the roof space and provide a dumb Internet pipe, another would sell you the device and yet another would install it for you -, who would be to blame?
Re:Feds now oppose Aereo, rejecting cloud apocalypse argument
by deelowe on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @05:43PM
(#7343751)
If they were, would this change your mind? What if they acted as if they were a subcontractor? At a certain point the line isn't so clear anymore. I don't know the correct answer here, but I'm concerned about the precedent this could set.