News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mopidy – Server which can play music from multiple sources by stingraycharles on Monday March 03, 2014 @07:25PM (#7337611)
I'm unfamiliar with both. How do they compare, and which would you recommend?
Re:Mopidy – Server which can play music from multiple sources by rdeboo on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @07:34AM (#7339792)
I've run both. They solve different, but related problems.

* Tomahawk is a desktop app. It integrates various music sources so you can play from whatever source is available. I can search for whatever and it will look on my local harddisk, on my Synology NAS, on Soundcloud, youtube, etc. It will play from the "best" source, determined by search match accuracy and bitrate. What's pretty cool is that it is integrated with Echonest (www.echonest.com) so you can define "Radio Stations" based on criteria like artist similarity, song mood, energy, etc. And those songs will be automatically resolved. My experience has been very good, everything works out of the box. Only the youtube resolver needs to be enabled manually (for copyright reasons).

* Mopidy, as far as I know, aims to do this on the server side. I've run an early version, I think 0.18 or something, on my Raspberry Pi. It involves some configuration to get it to work. Also, I don't think it can resolve songs in the way that Tomahawk does it: because MPD seems to have a static concept of the "Library". So you can import your Soundcloud "Liked songs", and they will be available in your library, but you cannot search for arbitrary songs. At least I didn't find that option.

A hybrid of both solutions would be awesome.

Re:Mopidy – Server which can play music from multiple sources by kingosticks on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:17AM (#7340253)
You can search for arbitrary songs with most extensions and I believe this includes mopidy-soundcloud. You must have used something much older than v0.18 as it was released about a month ago and needs no more configuration than any other media player i.e. where's the music. Finding a an MPD client that works how you want is the tricky bit.
Re:Mopidy – Server which can play music from multiple sources by rakoo on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @04:46AM (#7339296)
I'm also not completely familiar with tomahawk, although I have read quite a bit about it.

Tomahawk is a UI that has a standard "music player" behaviour. The sources are plugged in (they're called resolvers[0]), so that the core remains more or less the same.

AFAIU, mopidy acts a middle-man between sources (installed as plugins) and uis. It's more or less what playdar [1] (the ancestor of tomahawk) was, at least functionnally.

[0] https://github.com/tomahawk-player/tomahawk-resolvers [1] http://www.playdar.org/