News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:31PM (#7337362)
the real economy has a lot of idle resources

But many of those resources are idle because they were misallocated--for example, they were allocated to building more and more McMansions because of the housing bubble, rather than, for example, on fixing roads and bridges and other deteriorating infrastructure. Or they were allocated to building 18 million cars and light trucks a year in North America, when the market now demands only 11 million.

To some extent "helicopter money" as described in the article might help; perhaps if everyone got a $2000 check the demand for vehicles would go up to, say, 14 million a year. But would it go all the way back up to 18 million a year? I doubt it; a significant piece of that demand was people assuming that they needed a new car every 2-3 years; now many of them have had their cars for 5 or 6 years and are realizing that hey, they can save money by not buying a new car as often, without any real reduction in quality of life. That lost demand won't come back.

Nor should it. If the economy was set up to make stuff that people don't really need, that's a waste of resources that could be better allocated elsewhere. That's why I'm skeptical of the "aggregate demand" idea; it basically implies that all that's needed is for people to buy more stuff, without any analysis of the actual comparative value of the stuff.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by panarky on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:45PM (#7337435)
Sure, resources were misallocated. But we're now six years into this, it's been a largely jobless recovery, infrastructure is crumbling before our eyes, and those misallocated resources are now sitting idle.

If you forget about money for a second, it seems like there are a lot of jobs that need doing, and a lot of resources that are idle.

Bridges need to be built, highways need to be paved, kids need teachers and tutors, and we're firing cops and firefighters like never before.

Why can't we match up some of those jobs that need doing with the people, trucks, and factories that are idle?

Why isn't the free market doing a better job re-allocating those resources to more productive uses?

Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @01:58AM (#7338899)
it seems like there are a lot of jobs that need doing, and a lot of resources that are idle.

No argument here.

Why can't we match up some of those jobs that need doing with the people, trucks, and factories that are idle?

Because most bridges, highways, schools, police and fire departments, etc. are owned by governments, not by private industry, and governments suck at doing what you suggest.

Why isn't the free market doing a better job re-allocating those resources to more productive uses?

Because governments effectively have a monopoly on many of the productive uses that currently need resources (since they own the infrastructure that needs to be fixed).

Re:Free Money for Everyone by stanleydrew on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:42PM (#7338104)
There will always be misallocation of resources, because the environment we live in can't be perfectly predicted. People's tastes change, the climate changes, sometimes people die unexpectedly, etc. Unpredictability leads people to make investments based on uncertainty, and that will always lead to "mistakes".

Interestingly, the startup ecosystem is a little replica of this in which the best investors understand that capital in fact must be misallocated if we're going to find The Next Big Thing (tm) [1].

Anyway the point I want to make is that just because resources are misallocated doesn't mean we can't smooth the transitions to reallocation. In fact, I would argue that because some misallocation is healthy (otherwise we aren't taking enough risks), we should have in place a system which does smooth the transitions.

Basic income is a proposal for smoothing labor transitions, comparable to how bankruptcy smooths capital transitions.

[1] http://avc.com/2013/11/loss-ratios-in-early-stage-vc/

Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @02:10AM (#7338928)
There will always be misallocation of resources, because the environment we live in can't be perfectly predicted.

There will always be some misallocation due to this, yes. But the amount of misallocation due to, for example, the housing bubble was much more than can be explained just by our inability to perfectly predict the future.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @11:02PM (#7338385)
But helicopter money helps realize demand for things people actually want. If people don't want so many cars and want something else, some entrepreneur can borrow money, hire people and provide it. Borrowing to make money is good, borrowing for consumption is bad. We've been relying too much on the latter, as a nation.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @02:13AM (#7338935)
So basically, you're arguing that using "helicopter money" to create new demand will lead to the creation of new wealth by entrepreneurs. I would love to see this happen, but I'm pessimistic, because I don't think lack of consumer demand is the biggest obstacle faced by entrepreneurs. I think regulatory obstacles and entrenched monopolies in many sectors are bigger issues, and "helicopter money" won't solve those.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @08:44AM (#7340079)
By some mix of established companies and entrepreneurs. I agree that there are other issues as well, but there are large segments of the population whose wants and needs it is not very profitable to meet.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @09:29AM (#7340321)
there are large segments of the population whose wants and needs it is not very profitable to meet.

Did you mean to include the "not"? If so, why would established companies and/or entrepreneurs try to meet people's needs if it's not very profitable?

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @10:00AM (#7340536)
It is presently not very profitable, because they don't have the money to spend. If they had more money to spend, it would be more profitable. 50 million Americans below the poverty line - presumably they have wants and needs that aren't being met (or met well) because they don't have the money to express them in a way the market understands.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by pdonis on Tuesday March 04, 2014 @11:45AM (#7341321)
Ok, that makes it clearer.