News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by Mz on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:57PM (#7337158)
The problem is that it is like pouring water evenly over the surface of the globe, removing both oceans and continents. Yes, we need to find a way to more fairly and humanely distribute the available resources. I just don't think this is really it. If you tie it to nothing, it isn't likely to work or be sustainable.

What will it be tied to in order to ensure that it doesn't just wreck the economy? That piece seems to go unaddressed. My understanding is that in Alaska, everyone gets a check instead of paying taxes but it is because of the Alaska oil pipeline. When that pipeline runs dry. so will the "free money." It comes from somewhere. It doesn't just get printed out of thin air. Oil gets sold, the state redistributes the money to its citizens. It isn't just some magical manipulation on paper because money is relatively abstract, so people seem to think manipulating it really works. No, it really doesn't.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by nzp on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:22PM (#7337318)
Selling something (in this case oil) doesn't really make a difference. You haven't explained how is it different, you just said that it is different. All else being equal, what would change if Alaska just printed the money it now gets from selling oil? Because in current situation there is still some excess money that gets distributed "for free", so let's abstract the source of this money, and see if there is something wrong going on with Alaskan economy because of this "free money" being distributed.
Re:Free Money for Everyone by panarky on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:36PM (#7337402)
Yes, it's a mind-bender. My thinking used to center on the money, and the inevitable inflation if you debase money by printing more of it for free.

But the evidence of the last six years proves how wrong my thinking was. Dollars are not like shares of stock, that get diluted when you create more of them. When there's a lot of slack in the real economy, when people aren't working, and factories are idle, printing money doesn't cause inflation.

Today, I think about the real economy of workers and trucks and factories instead of money.

If we print $1000 per month per person and give it away for free, it's very possible to get the real economy moving, raise standards of living substantially, and incur very little cost in the real economy of work, goods and services.

For what it's worth, here's a radio show that turned my understanding of money upside down. Skip ahead to the 10th minute for the story on how Brazil created a totally fictitious virtual currency, named it the "real", and ended decades of debilitating inflation.

http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/423/t...

Re:Free Money for Everyone by dllthomas on Monday March 03, 2014 @09:32PM (#7338065)
"If we print $1000 per month per person and give it away for free, it's very possible to get the real economy moving, raise standards of living substantially, and incur very little cost in the real economy of work, goods and services."

I'm a staunch support of a moderate basic income, and I'm open to printing some of that, but this seems absurd. In the first year, you'd be printing more dollars than we have in circulation. I can't imagine demand for dollars would keep up.

Re:Free Money for Everyone by innguest on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:09PM (#7338195)
> When that pipeline runs dry. so will the "free money."

Only because you say so.

Now imagine the money doesn't stop flowing when the pipe runs dry.

You'll realize the connection we make between the pipeline and the checks Alaskans receive is completely imaginary.