Re:Free Money for Everyone
by notahacker on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:23PM
(#7336577)
Federal open market operations are not really a neutral policy. First of all, they buy assets in quantities designed to move the market price to a desired level which is really no more market-based than subsidising or taxing a particular product to fix its price. Secondly, the Fed conducts its open market operations through "primary dealers": a select list of registered financial institutions that meet certain capital requirements and are therefore nearly always divisions of major banks. The raison d'etre for its monetary policy is the stability of this banking system, and its effect is a massive subsidy to that sector. The fact regular individuals and firms can subsequently acquire these bonds is moot; money gifted to the citizenry will also trickle through to others.
Risk free interest offered to select financial institutions and flat payments to citizens are both distortionary transfers of real wealth. The argument for the former is that under most economic circumstances it's pretty efficient and open market operations are also effective at moving excess cash out of the system. The argument for the latter in some circumstances, especially as a one off stimulus, is that it's potentially much more efficient at stimulating demand than QE and potentially rectifies other structural imbalances.
Risk free interest offered to select financial institutions and flat payments to citizens are both distortionary transfers of real wealth. The argument for the former is that under most economic circumstances it's pretty efficient and open market operations are also effective at moving excess cash out of the system. The argument for the latter in some circumstances, especially as a one off stimulus, is that it's potentially much more efficient at stimulating demand than QE and potentially rectifies other structural imbalances.