News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by bowmessage on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:15AM (#7332451)
I wish they could just put themselves back online with the ~60% of users' bitcoins that they still have and just let us all withdraw them. Let us fight in court over the remaining 40%, right?
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by PeterisP on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:25AM (#7332639)
If having 60% of users Bitcoins were true, then doing what you propose would be a crime, and make the company officers personally liable to the customers who don't get their money.

As soon as the company knows it has 60% of the needed funds, then it is required to not allow anyone to withdraw their money. Instead, the insolvency process tries to treat everyone equally, so that they would pay out everybody 60% of their share, instead of some people getting all their money and some losing everything.

It is not optional, and not a choice that the company is allowed to make - they can affect the process on how exactly that happens (i.e., liquidating, restructuring as a running business, etc), but they can't simply pay out money to arbitrary debtors, that would open up many trivial ways of looting all the remaining money by insiders.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by roel_v on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:07AM (#7332746)
"Instead, the insolvency process tries to treat everyone equally, so that they would pay out everybody 60% of their share, instead of some people getting all their money and some losing everything."

No, there are a number of parties that get their money first, like the liquidator, the tax man, privileged creditors, etc. Which usually means that the concurrent creditors should be happy to get a few percent of their claims (the average here in the Netherlands is 3%).

Not disagreeing with your point, in fact reinforcing it - the proposal of the GP is preposterous under the law, and a flagrant violation of bankruptcy law across the world.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by t0mas88 on Monday March 03, 2014 @08:22AM (#7333536)
"(the average here in the Netherlands is 3%)" Only if you include the large number of (very) small businesses that fail, because most of those still have a substantial sum to pay to taxes, usually already-withheld income taxes and VAT.

For a case the size of Mt.Gox the average is higher. Remember DSB Bank? They even got above 100%, just took a long time to sort it all out.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by jameshart on Monday March 03, 2014 @10:58AM (#7334410)
That's predicated on the assumption that, from the point of view of the bankruptcy proceedings, the bitcoins are actually an asset considered in the bankruptcy - and more importantly that "being owed bitcoins" ranks you somewhere on the list of creditors. It's perfectly possible that the bankruptcy process would prioritize making people with real currency claims whole; if that means 'liquidating' bitcoin assets to turn them into dollars to pay back banks, liquidators, and other hard currency creditors, then that's what would happen.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by buro9 on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:36AM (#7332505)
This is equivalent to suggesting that the best course of action with a business that has gone bankrupt is to allow itself to be looted by some of its' customers.

Rather than attempting to rebuild value to return a higher proportion of cash/goods to all customers, or paying debtors according to contractual priority.

I think you're unlikely to get your wish.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by waterlesscloud on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:41AM (#7332683)
Not if you capped withdrawals at 60% of your balance.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by PeterisP on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:26AM (#7333171)
You'd need to know if it's really 60% and not, say, 59%; and you can't know that until the assets are actually liquidated - you can estimate the value of your stuff/buildings/whatever, but you'll know for sure only when they are actually sold.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by jobigoud on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:51AM (#7333054)
But how do you know whether the issues that caused the debacle are fixed or not? At that point it appears unclear that anyone knows the full details of the issues, including the MtGox team. Reopennig now might be risky.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by dustcoin on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:29AM (#7332486)
They don't have 60% of their customers' bitcoins. They (allegedly) have 0.2% (2k out of 750k) of their customers' bitcoins, and 60% of their USD/EUR/JPY.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by Aqueous on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:36AM (#7332504)
I really do not understand how the transaction malleability bug could have lost 40% of their fiat deposits.

Certainly they are not telling the truth about the transaction malleability. They have now dug their feet in on that explanation but it does not make sense given what we know about transaction malleability (the kind they are talking could not possibly have cause 850,000 bitcoins to disappear from allegedly cold storage without them noticing, and probably not without some social engineering.)

It seems likely that if the bug was involved somehow, it was because an intruder performed an attack from inside Gox . How else would they also be able to get fiat deposits out of Mt. Gox? Wouldnt that require initiating bank transfers?

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by nwh on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:42AM (#7332520)
It's basically impossible. There's 200BTC a day withdraw limits (or rather, was), for this to have worked somebody would have needed to be withdrawing the limit from 5 different accounts, every day for the last 3 years and successfully manipulating the bug in Gox's system every single time. This couldn't even have worked reliably, as the consistent Gox bug was only triggered by 0.8.0 being released.

It doesn't make sense as an explanation, especially given that we now know that some Russian clowns also had database access.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by nullc on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:05AM (#7332584)
> There's 200BTC a day withdraw limits

If you had a verified account you could ask for any limit you wanted up to 10k BTC, with a trusted account I think there was no maximum— I've talked to people who say they had 50k limits.

There was a 200 BTC maximum per withdraw however, at least in recent times.

> as the consistent Gox bug was only triggered by 0.8.0 being released

Even that wasn't consistent, only ~1% of signatures were invalid DER encodings with their code.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by nwh on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:23AM (#7332631)
> If you had a verified account you could ask for any limit you wanted up to 10k BTC, with a trusted account I think there was no maximum— I've talked to people who say they had 50k limits.

Wsn't aware of that, I only ever saw 200BTC being mentioned. Did Mt Gox seriously keep 10,000BTC+ in their hot wallet for this to work, or were manual withdraws like a bank where you make a cash request for the next day?

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by jlgaddis on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:42AM (#7333028)
> I've talked to people who say they had 50k limits.

That's certainly believable. My limit was 10k, IIRC, and I haven't used Mt. Gox since 2011.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by stock_toaster on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:05AM (#7332920)
> It doesn't make sense as an explanation, especially given that we now know that some Russian clowns also had database access

Big Red Shoes, Inc.? ClownCarDB?

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by nwh on Monday March 03, 2014 @06:35AM (#7333197)
A group of hackers that compromised Gox to find out "what went wrong" and compromised tens of thousands of people's passports and home addresses at the same times. Leaked the personal contacts and names of all the Gox employees, and generally put many people's lives genuinely at risk.

Clowns.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by choult on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:31AM (#7332818)
> I really do not understand how the transaction malleability bug could have lost 40% of their fiat deposits.

At what point, given normal business conditions, would you need to hold 100% of deposits? You only need enough to cover withdrawals; ignoring the MtGox issues 60% seems quite reasonable.

The only time you'd need to worry about 100% is if you're anticipating a total run on deposits or you're going to close the bank.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by commandar on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:37AM (#7333011)
>At what point, given normal business conditions, would you need to hold 100% of deposits?

At the point where you're not a lending bank, which Gox is not. They shouldn't have been running a fractional reserve at all.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by jordanthoms on Monday March 03, 2014 @05:33AM (#7332999)
Mt Gox wasn't (at least not openly) a fractional reserve bank - they need to have 100% of the customer funds on hand at all times.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by bowmessage on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:33AM (#7332500)
Ah, I didn't realize the units on their assets v liabilities reporting weren't bitcoins. Damn, thanks for pointing that out.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by alkimie2 on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:33AM (#7332499)
The announcement was silent on the BTC they still retain. I can't find any direct statements by anyone at Gox that all they have left is 2K. I'd be very grateful if someone could point it out if it exists.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by gst on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:30AM (#7332655)
The 2K BTC were mentioned on the leaked MtGox documents which were published one week ago or so. Given that many facts in those documents match with information that was published later on, it appears that those documents could be authentic.

See http://two-bit-idiot.tumblr.com/post/77988833128/the-final-g... for a link to the document and for more information.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by ars on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:22AM (#7332464)
They don't want to. They want to keep operating and slowly repay those 40% by transaction profits, and then continue operating after that as a profitable company.

They are crazy to think it will work. But that's what they want.

Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by makomk on Monday March 03, 2014 @04:49AM (#7332872)
Based on their own, incredibly optimistic, financial forecasts that were leaked earlier it'd take at least a decade for them to repay just the current USD value of what they've lost. I'm not sure it'd even be feasible for them to repay bitcoin for bitcoin, since their financial predictions quite likely rely on Bitcoin shooting up in value.
Re:Mt. Gox has posted a new update by pmorici on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:28AM (#7332483)
How do you figure they have 60% of the Bitcoins still? Everything I've read has said they only have about 2000 BTC left and they should have 750,000.