Re:Confessions of a Math Idiot
by dkarl on Thursday July 30, 2009 @06:26PM
(#733221)
I think what he's getting at is that the math taught in high school and applied college courses isn't fully formalized, often isn't fully explained, and even (as taught) contains ambiguities. I was a math major (and took graduate level analysis, topology, and set theory as an undergrad,) but the applied math classes I took felt really rushed and confusing. I actually felt kind of lost and dumb in sophomore DiffyQ, and what's worse, I was surrounded by engineering students who were having no problems. I sometimes felt dumb studying Lebesgue integration and transfinite induction, but I never felt lost like I did in DiffyQ. It didn't feel like math at all; I loved math but hated sophomore DiffyQ.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
My experience with math in school is that it was taught as if it were modern art: a bunch of meaningless procedures (up through calculus) and meaningless puzzles (beyond calculus).
If it were taught as providing some insight or serving some purpose, it might be a lot easier to learn and retain.