Re:Tweet Showing How Google Itself Is a “Scaper Site” Goes V...
by piyush_soni on Friday February 28, 2014 @03:46PM
(#7321374)
It actually adds a lot of value, at least for me. If you notice it doesn't show up these cards for all searches, but only for direct questions which it understands and can answer with fair enough reliability. It relieves people from the hassle of going to webpages to find the answer to their question. Most of the times, that's the only thing they are looking for. Your concern about eating away traffic from Wikipedia is correct, but the big question is what matters more to people in general - going on to a website just for the sake of it, or quickly getting their answers? When I ask my phone, "How old is Barack Obama?", it fetches the same from wikipedia, produces a 'Card', and reads the answer out to me. That is enormous value.
Re:Tweet Showing How Google Itself Is a “Scaper Site” Goes V...
by kevingadd on Friday February 28, 2014 @03:55PM
(#7321430)
That's not the sort of thing being discussed here, though. The example in the linked article is a search query that is literally the title of a Wikipedia page that is #1 in the results. You can find other examples for other queries. In these cases, Google adds zero value with the box but it is there anyway, depriving Wikipedia of traffic and user interaction.
Arguably if the source you're ganking content from is in the top 3 results, you might as well kill the scraped content box so that people can see more search results above the fold, since the content you scraped will be there anyway.
Of course, the boxes are good for Google, because they let them exert more control over visitors and traffic. Google puts enough of the source into the search results that the average visitor might never click through to Wikipedia.