I think you are misunderstanding what I'm saying. It isn't the currency's "job". It is a fundamental prerequisite that the currency have a backer for said currency to be used widely.
The mistake that people make with bitcoin is to put the cart before the horse. That is, they think that achieving critical mass [1] means that a currency has 'succeeded'.
In fact, you first need to provide a reason for people to trust the currency (central authority) which then leads to critical mass... and then 'success'.
The essence of bitcoin is ephemeral with no control, no central authority and no recourse. This stuff is built in. Unlike our current 'old style' currencies, bitcoin prides itself on standing apart this way.
When a currency is built in such a way that it EXPLICITLY removes the ability to have such necessary characteristics of a currency, you better believe it matters.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_mass_%28sociodynamics%...
Yes, that's a prerequisite for a currency to function as it should, but I think you're suggesting that Bitcoin differs from paper money in that regard.
It happens that people trust paper money, but this isn't because paper money has some kind of innate authority beyond public faith and trust. If a particular government chose to manipulate the currency they could destroy it, either quickly or slowly.
> The essence of bitcoin is ephemeral with no control, no central authority and no recourse.
I think you're exaggerating the role of "central authority".
http://w3.newsmax.com/newsletters/uwr/images/transcript-img1...
To me, the only difference between Bitcoin and paper money is public familiarity.
Why? Does it hold true after Bitcoin (rhetorical, we don't know yet)?
Certainly before the invention of Bitcoin and the ability to reach consensus in distributed systems, powerful/rich central authorities trigger initial trust and adoption. Hence you can see why previous digital currencies have been none-starters.
That you must first have "trust" and then comes a critical mass works for bitcoin, the currency, just fine, imo. I would say in fact that the initial seed has already been planted back in 2011 and we are seeing the growth now. Allow me to just regurgitate some things I know of bitcoin that give it some value/trust/seed for adoption:
- completely distributed, no middle-men (and their fees and risks and inefficiencies) except the 51% miners. This is the "reach consensus in distributed systems" which fixes double spending which is arguably the only real innovation of Bitcoin (of course there is more to the story, but this is the real new thing)
- used to be the main way to buy illegal drugs safely and conveniently in the U.S.
- great way to avoid paying taxes (WARNING: probably illegal where you live!)
- great way to do other illegal things online involving money (aka free trade, freedom of speech)
- _exceptional_ utility in transporting wealth
- _exceptional_ utility in transferring wealth (to someone else). i.e. medium of exchange
- _exceptional_ utility in being able to secure
- _exceptional_ unit of account because of specific measure, fungible, and divisible
- known supply and predictable production rate (automatic, built-in, preset control)
- deflationary (can't argue it's good for bootstrapping)
- impossible to counterfeit
Some drawbacks: - bad measure of value because of exchange volatility
- philosophical underpinnings or effects of being anti-state (see above pros) which also may have the effect of losing control of money creation and debt financing?
- deflationary and built-in control of supply (This is interesting. As I understand it from talking with a couple economists, the "infinite" divisibility may assuage traditional deflationary woes. Though they still generally have a feeling this is a con.)
- very infant, much risk
- will debt be possible, practical to build on top?
And sure, feel free to swap one or two pros/cons if you have reason.Is there anything in bitcoin's (the "currency") growth to suggest it _won't_ reach a tipping point? I ask because from my perspective it's adoption is ever growing, never stagnant.
Maybe we are actually mostly on the same page? I couldn't be sure but replied anyway. Did I miss this point:
>such necessary characteristics of a currency
It's more accurate to say that the dollar is backed by public familiarity, faith and trust. Some of that trust is in the government backing the currency, but if that were not true, if the government wasn't involved, it's interesting to ask how much of paper money's role and legitimacy could be supported only by public faith and trust in the currency and its connection with the economy. Assuming, that is, that the number of dollars in circulation could somehow be regulated without governmental control (a problem that the Bitcoin system addresses).
To each his own. Some think a central authority improves the reliability of a currency, some think the opposite. Let's ask Weimar-era Germans what they think:
http://c3445010.r10.cf0.rackcdn.com/landscape_image/5759/big...
(Humorously, the sign in the back -- "Rauchen Verboten" -- means "No Smoking". No sense burning up people's pocket money.)
> Otherwise, you're just dealing with gold, which is a regression.
You just posed a false choice. There are choices besides central authority and gold coins. Any currency in which people have faith and trust can be a legitimate currency on that basis alone. Of course, any currency must earn trust, and Bitcoin is nowhere near earning the public's trust.
My point was its equivalent to gold in the fact that it has no central authority controlling the supply.
>Let's ask Weimar-era Germans what they think
Oh yes, it had nothing to do with the massive amounts of money they were forced to pay in reparations and the rebuilding they had to do. By the way, no one ever said there wasn't a bad way to central bank. My argument is for good central banking, as Bernanke has done. Not the type of shit that Alan Greenspan did. (or the weimar republic). Just like I endorse democracy, but there are plenty of failed democracies. I could just as easily turn your weimar point back at you and say the great depression was because of the gold standard. Because we happened to have a gold standard at the same time. If we had central banking at that point, it could have mitigated a lot of the damage.