http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Ponzi_schemes
The fact that it doesn't fit the wiki or generally accepted definition of a Ponzi Scheme does not rule out the possibility that it still may be considered one but after spending some more time considering it, it does not look like a true Ponzi Scheme, even if the CEO did directly steal the money and use new money to pay old BTC buyers.
Suppose MtGox wasn't a bitcoin exchange, but rather sold cars, which had to be ordered and paid for in advance. Now, suppose further that the CEO "stole" cars from the company and then bought new ones using the money from new customers when he needed to deliver a car to one of the earlier customers. That's just plain old fraud, not a ponzi scheme, and it doesn't become a ponzi scheme just because it's money instead of cars - and in particular, you as an earlier customer certainly are not liable for the losses of later customers.
edit: I mean, MtGox under the assumption that the loss was not due to a technical problem, if it way due to a technical problem, it's obviously not a ponzi scheme anyway.
Madoff did not say "give me your money and you'll later get back the exact same amount, just minus some fees", I suppose? But that's what MtGox did - there was just no investment aspect to it.
It's like confusing eBay and paypal with some eBay seller: eBay and paypal don't sell clothes, say, they only help you find someone selling clothes and then (optionally) help with the settlement, the payment in particular.
And that's not just a formal distinction: On an exchange (like MtGox or any foreign currency exchange or stock exchange ...), the price for the traded commodity is not set by the exchange, but by the traders using the exchange. The exchange only sets the price for its service of connecting you with a counterparty, but the price for the stocks or bitcoins or whatever sold through the exchange is set by the trading partners, and the exchange also never takes on any of the investment risk, when you sell stocks, the counterparty gets the stocks, you get the money they paid, the exchange only does the bookkeeping.