Would this be just negligence?
So yes, MtGox is at least criminally negligent, and maybe simply criminal. But the (largely libertarian) crowds who chose to trust them are fully responsible for their own poor assessment of MtGox' trustworthiness. That's the flip-side of choosing deregulation.
If every time I want to buy a pack of gum I have to investigate every entity in the production and distribution chain, then I will never buy gum because the transaction cost is well above the value.
This is why businesses, who have substantial lobbying power, are generally ok with government regulation and often impose substantial self-regulation.
For example, take food. Restaurants here in San Francisco are all obliged to display their latest health department score. Almost everybody loves the system. Consumers love it because it tells them how safe their food is. Well-run restaurants love it because they can prove that their place is well run. Badly-run restaurants probably hate it, but that's fine; they're not good marketplace participants in the first place.
So your notion that you should go and check the oil level on every vehicle that ever contains any of your stuff is ridiculous. It's a handy way for you to feel smug blaming people who are suffering, not a reasonable suggestion for marketplace design.
I'll get negative poins again just because people don't like to be told what they should have known:
Bitcoins smell like a Ponzi scheme and, until they have proven themselves opposite, you should remain very wary of the money you put in. Do you invest in penny stocks? Nope. Why? Because they smell bad, even if their promoters make it look like they've quadrupled their value in just 4 months!
An online safe with millions of valuables? Shouldn't you wait for the proof it's good? Or do you assume it's a good safe as is? Is it really wise to assume something is safe? Oh I see negative HN points will rain on me. Not wise from me to put people in front of their responsibilities.
I'm sorry for people who lost money. Some of them will have a hard life. Losing money is never a good experience, I myself lost a quarter of my savings when the Australian dollar dropped. But do I blame the Australian gov? The EU gov? The regulators? Nope. It's my job to know when the AUD drops. Even if i can't inspect all parts of the economy. As a revenge, give me negative points.
That said, I don't think the average investor has the chops necessary to fully evaluate a bank, which is effectively what MtGox was. The information asymmetries are just too severe. In this case, depositors didn't lose money on Bitcoin itself, but in what was basically a bank collapse due to negligence or fraud. (Or both; we don't know yet.)
One solution is to always blame the victims. You can't go wrong there! But the solution that I prefer is to regulate banks, and forbid unregulated banks from operating in the regulators' jurisdictions. This oops-the-money-is-all-gone horseshit is exactly the kind of thing an auditor or a bank regulator would have spotted in their first week.
Hosting my emails in Gmail doesn't look safe either, to be honest, but at least it's not plain money and Google still needs to keep their reputation. For now.
But they were also dumb enough not to realize they were getting mugged, or so they claim.
Maybe I should have used "pick-pocketed" instead of mugged as an example.
I am not trying to give them an excuse but we don't seem to have enough anger against the criminals that caused this.
This is what I don't get, and which makes it hard to trust that they indeed "lost" this many coins. At the very least one would expect that for a company like this, they would regularly reconcile what the blockchain states the content of the wallets they control is, and what their internal customer records says should be there.
That's the very barest minimum I'd expect anyone to do. And the moment they found a discrepancy they should have suspended everything until they'd figured out why there was a discrepancy.
If they've truly managed to keep losing coins over years, it means they had no effective audit mechanisms in place at all.
Whoever took these coins certainly also is to blame, but if they've managed to lose the coins that way, this ought to be criminal levels of negligence.
http://falkvinge.net/2014/02/28/the-gox-crater-crowd-detecti...
http://letstalkbitcoin.com/the-ghost-in-the-machine-at-mtgox...
If true, how can MtGox prove it lost the key? If he walks away, he can wait 10 years and then transfer the funds out and spend them.
But if false, can we demand he produce the key?
What if someone else entirely different has the key?
It's all fascinating.
Claims that MTGox has a lot of coin so far look completely spurious to me.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1z3v4k/claims_that...
In Falkvinge's case, it may be wishful thinking. He has also posted that he had 160 BTC and 1500 euros on Mt.Gox
For them to turn around and lose 750,000 BTC is not analogous to being innocently mugged. It's more like a taxi driver guaranteeing a safe trip, actually driving drunk, then crashing and killing the passenger.
Investing in alternative investments is speculative, not suitable for all clients, and intended for experienced and sophisticated investors who are willing to bear the high economic risks of the investment, which can include: -loss of all or a substantial portion of the investment due to leveraging, short-selling or other speculative investment practices; -lack of liquidity in that there may be no secondary market for the fund and none expected to develop; -volatility of returns; -restrictions on transferring interests in a fund; -potential lack of diversification and resulting higher risk due to concentration of trading authority when a single advisor is utilized; -absence of information regarding valuations and pricing; -delays in tax reporting; -less regulation and higher fees than mutual funds; -funds of hedge funds often have a higher fee structure than single manager funds as a result of the additional layers of fees; -risks associated with the operations, personnel, and processes of the manager.
There is not one single official statement from anyone to the effect that there has been an external theft from Mt. Gox. No one has reported a theft to police.
There is zero basis to believe an external theft has occurred.
If Mt. Gox does file a police report, at least then someone has done something (with official penalty for false statement) indicating that they believe a theft has occurred, and some possibly-accurate information would be available. But for now, there is nothing to stand behind a claim of external theft.
When someone gets mugged it's simple to be sympathetic to what's happened.
When someone gets mugged and you gave them assets to hold and/or transfer, and they didn't take due care of the security of these assets, this makes them culpable and negligent.
Yes, MtGox are probably having a really shit time right now, and yes I'd feel sorry for anyone who'd just fucked up this royally (assuming there was definitely no intent to defraud on their part), but that sympathy is tempered by a recognition that they've made the world vanish from under thousands of peoples feet as they see assets they trusted with the exchange float away into the ether.
This is why managing risk and having rules that protects consumers is so useful. Everyone's a hedgefund investor until suddenly the rug gets pulled out from under their feet.
What leads you to believe this?
But I guess on the other hand we do have to realize they are victims of massive theft, as far as we know this massive loss was not due to their own profiteering or internal theft, it was an organized outside force targeting them.
It occurs to me it is like blaming someone for getting mugged, although they were stupid enough to walk down a really bad street at a bad time of night with their cash out in their hands, it did take a criminal to make the crime happen, not the victim.