Re:Obama's Trauma Team: Inside the Nightmare Launch of Healt...
by yummyfajitas on Friday February 28, 2014 @02:11AM
(#7317561)
I also know better than to change the criteria after the study starts. A study was proposed. None of the critics of the study had anything negative to say about it until after the results were in - that's probably because they thought it would vindicate the 45,000 number.
Re:Obama's Trauma Team: Inside the Nightmare Launch of Healt...
by Fomite on Friday February 28, 2014 @03:09AM
(#7317663)
Actually looking at the results isn't "changing the criteria", it's looking at the results in a more nuanced way than null hypothesis testing.
I would have said that looking at chronic health outcomes after just a few years was probably a losing proposition, and asked to see some power calculations, or a longer term analysis plan.
I've done so for other studies. Was actually grousing about one in a meeting...two weeks ago?
Someone who works for 'Bayesianwitch' should know better than to rely on p = 0.05 as the sole basis on which to evaluate something.