News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by cperciva on Saturday October 27, 2007 @02:57AM (#73113)
Does any code which people download and run locally count? I'm building an online backup utility -- but I'm planning on giving the code away for free and charging for the storage space, so it's not a "pure" desktop application like a word processor.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by rms on Saturday October 27, 2007 @05:27AM (#73130)
I'm curious how you plan on implementing your open source/free business model. Are you going to use a BSD license? GPL 2 or 3?

Let's say I had a company that wanted to compete with your company -- how do you prevent me from making a different GUI for your software and aggressively marketing my version, perhaps with in-house developed features that aren't open source? Is this difficult/undesirable to prevent?

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by brl on Saturday October 27, 2007 @08:24AM (#73158)
I'm going to answer this too because we are in the situation you are describing. We are writing a platform that we intend to release under a liberal no-strings-attached free software license (ie: not GPL).

We're not worried at all about people taking our code and using it to build proprietary products. In fact, we are going to encourage people to do exactly that because, as far as we can see, other companies having a vested interest in our platform is pretty much a win-win situation for everybody.

Of course as a business, we have revenue generating activities with the platform planned for ourselves, but it really seems unlikely that another company would choose to compete head on with us about that. We wrote the platform after all, so there are many different ways we could rain on their parade if they decide to use our software in an antagonistic way.

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by izak30 on Saturday October 27, 2007 @10:38AM (#73172)
In which ways could you 'rain on their parade'? stop supporting your software? change the license? They could just hire talented coders to use and update your base from the last point that you did update, or the last point that you had that license. Right? I'm not trying to antagonize you, just trying to understand the legalities of the open-source side of capitalism.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by brl on Saturday October 27, 2007 @11:16AM (#73180)
We could relicense components that they need under a less business friendly license so that they could not take advantage of future improvements to the platform.

But yes, they could then pick up that development on their own by forking the platform from an older version.

The most important way that we could 'rain on their parade' though is just by being way better than them at creating applications based on the platform since we will always understand the internals better than anybody else.

We only want to reserve a small number of commercial opportunities for ourselves out of a large number of possibilities. Cooperating with us to develop one of those other possible product ideas is going to seem a lot more attractive than competing directly with us.

Please don't worry at all about challenging our ideas about this stuff. We are trying to understand the same things you are and our open source business strategy is largely theoretical at this point.

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by corentin on Sunday October 28, 2007 @01:56PM (#73464)
> We could relicense components that they need under a less business friendly license so that they could not take advantage of future improvements to the platform.

Why not doing it in the first place, then?

> The most important way that we could 'rain on their parade' though is just by being way better than them at creating applications based on the platform since we will always understand the internals better than anybody else.

If the internals are not well-designed and not well-documented, yes. In that case, once again, why bother releasing the source code?

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by brl on Monday October 29, 2007 @05:19AM (#73718)
> Why not doing it in the first place, then?

We don't want to do it at all and probably never would. I'm only mentioning it as something that somebody evaluating risks from the other side might imagine that we could do.

> If the internals are not well-designed and not well-documented, yes. In that case, once again, why bother releasing the source code?

No, we're not going to deliberately obfuscate anything because that would be against our goals of encouraging as many people as possible to adopt our platform.

I think it's not really necessary to create artificial obstacles for us to have an important advantage. Very large systems take time and experience to understand even when they are both well designed and well documented.

Linus and Alan Cox have an advantage over newcomers at extending the Linux kernel, right? Hypothetically, if Linus, Alan, and say Rusty Russell got together and created a startup to implement a Linux kernel based idea, would it make sense to compete against them on exactly that idea?

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by corentin on Monday October 29, 2007 @02:21PM (#73862)
It would make sense: while they would spend their time debugging and fine tuning their beloved baby of a kernel you would just use their work and add value on top of it.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by raganwald on Sunday October 28, 2007 @02:18PM (#73468)
> The most important way that we could 'rain on their parade' though is just by being way better than them at creating applications based on the platform since we will always understand the internals better than anybody else.

Bill Gates, is that you?

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by cperciva on Saturday October 27, 2007 @07:05AM (#73142)
I said that the code was going to be free, not that it was going to be freely licensed. Users will be able to see the source code, but it will be "look, but don't touch" license.

Open Source is great, but after spending a year working on this I don't want end up competing with someone else who is using my code.

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by corentin on Saturday October 27, 2007 @05:53AM (#73135)
If I were him, my main selling point would be trust. That is, I would trust him much more with my data than any random guy who copied his code (because he really knows computer security and cryptography and because he has some credentials, too: he's FreeBSD security officer).

If you wanted to compete with him on this ground (trust and security), you'd need to be a good security hacker too and obviously you wouldn't need to copy his code because you could write it yourself.

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by cperciva on Saturday October 27, 2007 @07:13AM (#73144)
Trust my ability, not my morality. I'm just as vulnerable to court orders, extortion, and corrupt datacentre technicians as the next guy, so you shouldn't be trusting that I'll never try to steal your data. If someone puts a gun to my head, OF COURSE I'll try to steal your data.

However, if I've done my job properly, I'll fail -- because the first design principle behind tarsnap is that nobody will be able to steal your data, even if they force me to cooperate with them.

Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by jamiequint on Saturday October 27, 2007 @08:23AM (#73157)
How are you planning to scale better than amazon s3 in terms of cost? If someone were to build an open source thin layer storage/backup client on top of s3 you would effectively be dead.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by cperciva on Saturday October 27, 2007 @12:48PM (#73196)
I'm not planning to compete with S3 on cost. I'm planning to compete with S3 on features -- an encrypted snapshotted backup system is vastly better than one which just copies files onto S3.
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by boucher on Saturday October 27, 2007 @01:22PM (#73206)
But what prevents you from building an encrypted snapshot and storing it on S3?
Re:Ask News.YC: Is anyone building a desktop application? by cperciva on Saturday October 27, 2007 @01:46PM (#73216)
Nothing except code. Taking second snapshot and only storing the differences is a bit harder. Deleting the first snapshot while leaving the second snapshot intact is even harder.