I think your example of a Starbucks is a good one, and I'd be curious to know. The attacker has to go and physically sit in or near the Starbucks to do it, which is a strong limitation. They also have to have to have something worthwhile to do with what they steal. So that limits it to criminals with the knowledge to exploit this MITM attack who are willing to sit outside a Starbucks for long enough to harvest a worthwhile set of credentials.
I doubt that many credentials were stolen this way.
But some were, right?
Again, what's the upside to waiting? It looks like zero to me. Minor convenience for Apple at best. Placing their own convenience over the security of their customers is bad.
How many Macs connected to Starbucks WiFi this weekend and had their e-mail and banking credentials lifted? If my hat were darker, I'd have been out there doing it for fun if nothing else.
The fact that it requires a MITM means you're fairly safe on a home connection, but there are lots of people out there on public WiFi who would be pretty vulnerable to this.
I really don't understand what the "gamble" is. What's the upside to waiting?