News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @06:29AM (#7296967)
The tone of condescension that comes from professional economists is telling. It's impossible for them to just present their arguments, cleanly, simply and without ostentation and vitriol. They have to try to make you feel stupid for disagreeing with them.

When you don't have a sound scientific basis for your discipline, you need something to step in to fill the void - in order to make other humans believe in your worth. Economists use their enormous egos, as well as the frailties inherent in the egos of others.

Heather R Morgan has not written an article which rises above the flaws of her discipline. It starts with a jibe - oh, you invested in bitcoin, why not flush it down the toilet - that's HOW STUPID YOU WOULD BE...

Engineers and hackers don't have to worry about whether or not their discipline makes a genuine contribution. They have proved themselves time and time again. They build a product - ship it - and if it fails, they start working on the next idea. They don't have to worry about fighting over 'theories' with academics who desperately claw at one another for those disappearing tenure tracks.

As we who have spruiked for bitcoin have always said: "This is an experiment that might fail."

Heather might want to consider switching to a discipline in which experiments are even possible...

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by lclarkmichalek on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @06:41AM (#7297001)
You haven't commented on the content of the article at all. I know attacking the tone is easy, but it's hardly constructive.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @06:45AM (#7297012)
Well - I think it's important to address the tone. I was going to say more about the substantive argument - but didn't because I didn't want to write a wall of text. Also, I just see the argument as a very uncritical regurgitation of the intrinsic value argument against bitcoin and I've personally grown weary trying to encourage a greater level of depth to that discussion.

If you are interested - I've written at (great) length my thoughts about this argument here:

http://reviewsindepth.com/2013/12/bitcoin-krugman-and-the-me...

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by williamcotton on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:46AM (#7297236)
> Bitcoin really is a currency of “mere agreement” then you can begin to see that its mainstream acceptance will genuinely herald the dawn of a new age of human civilisation. And don’t be too quick to take that last statement as hyperbolic praise – it might be a statement of supreme pessimism about its potential for success, depending on your point of view.

Have you considered a career in science fiction or as a song writer?

"I'm torn between the light and dark, Where others see their targets, Divine symmetry. Should I kiss the viper's fang, Or herald loud, the death of Man. I'm sinking in the quicksand, of my thought, And I ain't got the power anymore."

I think David Bowie put it a little bit better and he did come up with a pretty great melody and chord progression for the tune, but don't let that get you down, you gotta start somewhere, right? I think he said it better because he had the ability to discern the difference between fantasy and reality. He then learned to channel his apocryphal visions in to art. You're wasting your talents here in reality, my friend!

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:57AM (#7297295)
Well - that's certainly the most charming jibe I've received about my writing. I tip my hat to you sir.

I would be keen to know your opinion after reading the whole article. I assume you haven't - because I do at least make an argument for that claim, and you don't attempt to address it before calling me deluded. Given the large amount of effort I put into that article, don't you think I might deserve this much at least?

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by williamcotton on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @08:23AM (#7297419)
Another thing you could learn from Bowie is how to write succinctly.

Listen dude, I don't think Bitcoin is valueless. It is an interesting solution to a number of technical challenges in distributed computing. It may even very well work as some sort of digital currency.

What I don't think is that it is going to change the world. You and every other maniac out there is actually doing a disservice to the acceptance of the technology. What kind of loony expects someone to read a 10,000 word essay that starts off with some sweeping claim about how 'everything's different now!'?

You don't know shit about the world. You couldn't possibly have enough experience or knowledge to piece together any sort of valid prediction, just like every other motherfucker out there. You've just got faith in some grand tale that honestly isn't that different from any other end-of-time story, like say, the Book of Revelations.

You're right to point the finger at economists when they make grand sweeping claims. They're just storytellers. There's a reason it is considered a liberal art.

Computer programmers and engineers aren't much more than storytellers either. There is even more danger of delusion in software because entire virtual worlds are created and then assumed to be real.

Math is the language of nature.

Truth is the language of man.

Learn to tell the difference.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @08:56AM (#7297581)
Oh dear, you're a very vituperative fellow.

I don't expect you to read it at all. I couldn't give a tinker's cuss if you do or don't. Generally though, if you don't want to look like a fool, it's best not to express an opinion about a piece you haven't read.

The claim you are so hostile to is actually not even particularly controversial. It's a conditional statement for one thing (you don't even read an introduction carefully) and it's easily defended. It's a fact that no currency has ever been widely adopted without having some kind of intrinsic or government mandated value. Plain, historical fact. Bitcoin has no intrinsic or government mandated value. So if it gains widespread adoption, then I don't see how you could possibly deny the historical significance of this. A large amount of economic orthodoxy goes out the window.

If you are willing to address this argument, I'm willing to listen. But if you're just here to beat your chest and get all alpha on me then I might point out you're better off hitting the gym and cruising the bars. It's more likely to get you laid than arguing with me.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by williamcotton on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @09:13AM (#7297660)
The claim I'm hostile to is ANYONE making grand claims without acknowledging that it is all just story telling.

Arguing with you about your faith in the world changing powers of Bitcoin would be like arguing with a Christian about the Bible.

I'm not saying that Bitcoin is useless. I'm not saying it is without value.

I'm saying that the kind of zealotry you're exhibiting is nauseating and nothing new.

There are vast capital machinery in place entwined with giant military fleets, tax collectors, fiat currency and billions of democratically elected positions of power. That shit has a lot of inertia and the concepts are so interdependent on one another that you can't just slot out 'US dollars' and drop in 'bitcoin'. Farmers and soldiers don't give two shits about your blog posts.

If you want to change the world you will have to deal with... the world.

The problem with bitcoin or tech or Christianity or any other kind of ideological zealotry is that you're basically putting on blinders and ignoring the world because you're so convinced that what you're doing is the only thing that matters.

"The rest of the world doesn't matter because it will all change so drastically that I don't need to know anything about it!"

Again, there is nothing wrong with bitcoin, tech, or Christians... Just zeal applied to grand narratives.

Getting my drift yet, dude?

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @09:41AM (#7297803)
Would I be a zealot if I said the printing press precipitated a revolution in human society and culture? I'm just saying something similar about bitcoin IF it meets certain conditions in the future. If you bothered to read the article you would notice that I'm sceptical that it actually will.

Anyway - we're done here. I made a claim and presented an argument. You chastised that claim without reading the argument or even addressing the summarised version I just wrote for you. I am willing to listen to a counter-argument and consider it, but you refuse to provide one. So this is a waste of both our time.

I don't get how you can behave this way and yet accuse me of behaving like a religious zealot. Refusing to actually address an argument for a claim, while at the same time attacking that claim feels a lot like all the of the conversations I've had with zealots myself.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by jpttsn on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @06:43AM (#7297007)
Grandparent has a valid point about the article's tone, and attacking tone can be constructive.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by k-mcgrady on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:00AM (#7297053)
>> As we who have spruiked for bitcoin have always said: "This is an experiment that might fail."

It's fine to experiment but when Bitcoin became more mainstream the kind of stupid mistakes MtGox has made are inexcusable. Ordinary people were using it and are losing money now. You can't promote a new technology and push for it's adoption by a wide audience and just call it an experiment when it fails. That's reckless.

>> Heather might want to consider switching to a discipline in which experiments are even possible...

And you're complaining about condescension?

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by matthewmacleod on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:18AM (#7297109)
Can I be blunt? It's their own goddamned fault.

I get that MtGox made a lot of obviously severe errors in implementation. But I'm also aware that popular wisdom has been (for some time) to avoid it. And further, it should be immediately obvious to anybody with a shred of sense that you do not hand over piles of cash (which is the closest approximation to Bitcoin) to an unregulated, opaque private enterprise.

Yeah, it sucks for the people who lost money. But with the exception of a minority, they were obviously dabbling with things they did not understand.

Nothing about this speaks at all to the long-term viability of Bitcoin as a currency. In fact, I think it'll probably be a benefit in the long-term - there needed to be a large, damaging demonstration of the requirement for security, and this event will cause a lot of changes.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:11AM (#7297090)
I presume the 'you' in your statement is directed at... well... who exactly? Who was promoting Bitcoin in a way that did not foreground its extreme risk front and center? Your journalistic finger wagging will not do here. I would like to see examples. And if you provide them, then I will accept in each such case that they were indeed irresponsible.

As for my last statement - I accept it comes off as no better. But I happen to actually mean it with more sincerity than you can possibly imagine. I was a PhD student in philosophy. After five years I quit because I couldn't stomach my own bullshit any more. I'm currently training myself in math, machine learning and programming. Even as a mediocre tech guy (and I don't doubt I'll ever be more than mediocre) - I'll add more value to the world than I ever did as a philosopher. I believe the same of economics.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by dnautics on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:42AM (#7297212)
I was cheering when you wrote that. I have a PhD in chemistry, where we actually do experiments, and am an armchair economist. I quit my science job to temporarily work for lyft while waiting on the IRS for 501(c)(3) status on a nonprofit I'm launching - and with lyft I do real-time economics, gauging supply and demand on a minute-by-minute basis, and observe whether or not my models are confirmed. It would do well for academic economists to actually get that level of experiential model-testing, informal as it may be. Obviously, they don't (I did undergrad at U of Chicago, I know the econ department there).

EDIT: Speaking of economic models and confirmation:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6867999

Also, a careful examination of the bitcoin chart reveals that it does not look like the traditional bubble (yet). Go to http://bitcoinity.org/markets and set it to 2 years and log scale (hidden control in upper left of the graph). The chart, rather, looks like this: https://duckduckgo.com/traffic.html Which is a web platform growth curve.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by davidw on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:23AM (#7297131)
Economics is fascinating. It's a fairly new discipline, and like, say, astronomy, conducting experiments can be tricky, but throwing the whole thing out is silly. There is a lot to be learned for those interested in learning, rather than just backing up their own political view of the world.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by glimmung on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @08:13AM (#7297371)
There is another huge difference, aside from the susceptibility to experiment of the two fields - in astronomy one studies an objective natural system, in the other one studies a subjective human-driven environment.

The thing that troubles me most about economics is its apparent inability to address the fact that it cannot (yet?) make even modestly accurate predictions, and seems to be in denial about the implications of that fact.

To be honest, I lost all interest in economics-as-science when I learned that its theories were based on the idea that people were "rational actors" - this so flies in the face of my life experience that it simply doesn't pass the smell test.

I wouldn't throw the /whole/ thing out, but we have to be realistic about its limitations, and the fact that small changes in human sentiment or worldview may potentially completely invalidate its core assumptions.

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by makomk on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @10:26AM (#7298053)
Also, in astronomy, the stars aren't actively searching for and exploiting flaws in your models, whereas in economics the main actors very definitely are.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by grovulent on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:37AM (#7297189)
Well - I wasn't advocating that it should be entirely dismantled as a discipline. But I do believe it should be avoided by those with the sort of personality that would seek to make up for its flaws with their egotism. That's why I offered that suggestion to the author.
Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by moe on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:07AM (#7297073)
MtGox != Bitcoin.

Why is that so hard to understand?

Re:The Bitcoin Economics lesson for Engineers by perfunctory on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @07:29AM (#7297156)
> They build a product - ship it - and if it fails, they start working on the next idea.

Insert "economic theory" instead of "product".