Google "Cogent peering dispute" you will see they have had problems with nearly every tier 1 out there. They sell bandwidth very cheap and then try to work out settlement free agreements. The problem is their network often times ends up pushing much more traffic onto the peer than they deliver themselves.
Netflix is a customer of Cogent's and as many customers of them know they often have disputes. Netflix is large enough now where they can pay at interconnects for transit and not have to deal with Cogent's oversubscribed network.
This is not the death of net neutrality. This is how the internet has always worked. To peer settlement free the networks need to be on near equal terms. If you are a small business you simply pay someone who has this peering worked out.
In this instance Comcast is not discriminating against traffic from Netflix in particular, it is discriminating against a peer network that is not paying settlement and providing a non mutually beneficial connection. That is business and is how the internet has always worked since it left the NSF.
Of course, UPS doesn't have a monopoly, so they can't get away with that crap. But they reveal the truth: this is all about leverage.
More to the point, in the US there's often only two players, a DSL and a cable provider, so little meaningful choice.
Forget about Netflix here for a moment this is a network agreement. If you are Cogent Comcast can say: You are providing bulk bandwidth cheaply and delivering a huge amount of traffic to our network. You are not providing our customers or us with significantly greater connectivity, and far less of our traffic is going over your pipes. Pay us or we are not going to take more of your traffic.
There is absolutely zero chance Cogent will ever recieve more data from Verizon then Verizon receives from cogent.
So the Teir 1 Providers that also just so happen to be last Mile Providers have created this nice little scam whereby they can double bill and call it "peering"
Netflix does not really make that much in profit. I see a rate hike coming soon
This is not unlike government regulation that "exempts" small business....
All this does is put an effective ceiling on a business. You will never be allowed to grow beyond X with out having to pay your protection money.
This hurts startups because VC and other investors want the business to grow beyond X and knowing their is an upper limit to the growth will make it very hard if not impossible to get investment.