It's based on: $200 trillion in assets + $700 billion in military spending + $16 trillion GDP + 7,700 nuclear warheads (per FAS). Then throw in 313 million people with one of the highest GDP per capita and average income rates, plus the third largest country by geographical size (with prime positioning on both major oceans). There's also the USD as global reserve currency, which today has no serious competitor for that status.
China for example will likely soon be a formal superpower, and it won't be because everybody loves their government.
Isolation can sting, no question, but realistically unless we're talking North Korean or Cuban style isolation, it has minimal bearing on superpower status.
The next power status bearer won't be any different, though. That's how international relations have rolled in the past, and that's how they'll continue to be.