News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by presidentender on Sunday February 23, 2014 @06:56PM (#7288305)
Why should the tech sector be tied to any one place?
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by fennecfoxen on Sunday February 23, 2014 @07:23PM (#7288409)
It's not tied to any one place. It is tied to a few places, and Silicon Valley more strongly than most: in no small part because you can hire programmers there, because programmers live there, because they can get hired there (all circular-referency-like).

But it's also tied to places like New York, and London, and Seattle, and Boston, and Austin, heck, Shanghai and Hong Kong and Bangalore -- any place where there's enough of a critical mass of reasonably well-educated raw population that "programmers live there" because everyone lives there. Not tied as strongly, mind you -- the network effect and the venture capital in the bay area are hard to beat. But tied enough that it works.

Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by toomuchtodo on Sunday February 23, 2014 @07:47PM (#7288491)
Can't programmers work remotely? And can you not work remotely if your management isn't totally incompetent? "You can't manage what you can't measure." and all that jazz.

In short, the SFBA crisis is caused by the tech culture not drinking its own Koolaid about geography not mattering.

Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by ufmace on Sunday February 23, 2014 @08:17PM (#7288572)
I've done some remote work, and found it to be mixed at best most of the time. I think part of the problem is that, for it to really work, the entire organization has to completely change their methods of work around it. If there's even one remote worker, the entire workforce has to commit to doing everything online, even if they're in the same space, or else the remote worker is shut out. Even if you're right next to your co-worker, all of your interaction has to be over email/chat/whatever you're using. Everyone you might want to talk to has to be as available on chat/IM as they are in their office.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by argonaut on Sunday February 23, 2014 @09:20PM (#7288759)
The koolaid you speak of is only propogated by the few companies that actually do hire remote. GitHub and 37signals/Basecamp are two examples that immediately come to mind.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by toomuchtodo on Sunday February 23, 2014 @09:23PM (#7288773)
Github and Basecamp are companies I'd identify as fairly successful. If they can do it, why are Google, Facebook, Yahoo, and Amazon so bad at it?
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by argonaut on Sunday February 23, 2014 @09:27PM (#7288781)
GitHub only has 240 employees. Google has around 50,000. Bad comparison. It's like saying "Ruby on Rails works for GitHub; if they can do it, why can't Google use Ruby on Rails?"

If you read any of their articles on how they make remote work for them, they do it by and organizing the entire company around remote work, IIRC. And they still have offices.

Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by toomuchtodo on Sunday February 23, 2014 @09:44PM (#7288828)
So Google isn't broken down into departments? And departments broken down into projects?

This feels less like decision making based on results and more like hand waving by bad managers.

Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by argonaut on Sunday February 23, 2014 @11:29PM (#7289093)
And projects don't talk to each other? And departments don't talk to each other? And departments don't report to inter-department leads/heads? There aren't Director or VP level managers?
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by toomuchtodo on Sunday February 23, 2014 @11:40PM (#7289121)
If only there were some sort of text and voice based communications methods we could use to facilitate the transfer of information between disparate groups...
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by nknighthb on Sunday February 23, 2014 @08:04PM (#7288540)
There is no consensus in "the tech culture" on the value of remote work. You've confused pundits and politicians with techies.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by pistle on Sunday February 23, 2014 @08:05PM (#7288541)
Which may well mean that the Koolaid is a fabrication by a segment of the tech industry to move units and subscriptions.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by ufmace on Sunday February 23, 2014 @08:22PM (#7288598)
Why shouldn't it? It seems to be a huge reduction in friction of all types to have everything in the same place. Not just coders, but investors, people willing to start companies, accountants and lawyers specializing in the field, marketing, graphic design, etc. Face-to-face interactions are simple, and always work. The multitude of internet-based remote-work assistants all seem to have their own issues and limitations.
Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by rbanffy on Sunday February 23, 2014 @07:14PM (#7288379)
This, sir, is a mystery we have not yet solved. It has to do with a critical mass of talent and companies, social dynamics and financials.

Silicon Valley is not easily replicated.

As for me, a person who visits the place on vacations, I love it. I wish I could do more to solve its many problems.

Re:What if the critics win, and tech sector flees S.F.? by peatmoss on Sunday February 23, 2014 @07:30PM (#7288427)
Agglomeration economies.