Re:Apple's SSL/TLS bug
by lukasLansky on Saturday February 22, 2014 @12:59PM
(#7282856)
There is a context missing. The Dijkstra quote is really old (Wikipedia dates it to 1975) and do not talk about "modern Basic" we know, with a good support for structured programming -- it's about a language where GOTO's were used instead of proper loops. It's certainly still an exageration to speak about "brain corruption", but I think I know why he put such emphasis on the statement.
- The bug here has nothing to do with GOTO.
- Dijkstra said a lot of stupid things, this is one of them. Parsimonious use of GOTO is fine and sometimes leads to clearer code (exiting deeply nested conditions for example).
- Another stupid thing that Dijkstra said is that anyone who started by learning BASIC has their brain corrupted forever, which is total nonsense (I bet most people reading this started with BASIC and turned out just fine).