Re:Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax,...
by akiselev on Friday February 21, 2014 @09:27PM
(#7280734)
To dismiss a paper on perpetual motion machines you just need to know the implications of the first or second law of thermodynamics, about which there is, for all intents and purposes, unanimous consensus.
To dismiss attempted translations of the Voynich manuscript, you'd need to read the attempted translation because there is no consensus whatsoever about the manufascript, except for the fact that it is untranslated.
Re:Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax,...
by bronson on Saturday February 22, 2014 @01:44AM
(#7281204)
That would only be true if every attempted translation were unique.
In other words, once you've dismissed one paper barking up the wrong tree you can confidently dismiss all the others that appear to be barking up the same tree.
Re:Voynich Manuscript partially decoded, text is not a hoax,...
by alexeisadeski3 on Friday February 21, 2014 @09:27PM
(#7280733)
Perpetual motion machines are known to be metaphysically impossible. Decoding this is not.
Does that make any commentary that you might make on the subject utterly worthless?