I don't think this generalizes as well as you think it does. Even in technology, credentials haven't become un-important, just less so, and I think it's the furthest along that path. I suspect most of these kids want to be successful doctors, lawyers, scientists, (non-software-) engineers, or "traditional" business management rather than hackers, and credentials are still the way to do those things, and will be for the foreseeable future.
> I suspect most of these kids want to be successful doctors, lawyers, scientists, (non-software-) engineers, or "traditional" business management rather than hackers, and credentials are still the way to do those things, and will be for the foreseeable future.
In the case of doctors and lawyers (and engineers in many cases), there is a legal requirement to have credentials in order to be involved in practice.
I believe it is different in the US, but in the UK, experience is valued most regarding hacking (IT work). A CS degree holds little water, since many of them are, well, inadequate.
It is not that credentials are not needed--in my example, Johnny Lee still has credentials--but that it is not essential to gain the very best credentials in order to find work where one's creativity matters.
Re:Go Ahead, Let Your Kids Fail
by mathattack on Sunday February 23, 2014 @09:50PM
(#7288855)
We say they aren't important, yet we get impressed by MIT and Google on a resume.
That doesn't quite work. UVA is, along with Michigan and Berkeley and UCLA, among the top 4 public schools in the US.
Re:Go Ahead, Let Your Kids Fail
by alexeisadeski3 on Saturday February 22, 2014 @02:12AM
(#7281247)
That factoid doesn't contradict his point.
Students who think that credentials are everything won't be looking at UVA and Michigan except for specific programs they may have.
Hmm? Anyone who knows anything knows UVA is one of the best schools in the nation for a wide variety of disciplines.
Re:Go Ahead, Let Your Kids Fail
by alexeisadeski3 on Saturday February 22, 2014 @12:27PM
(#7282747)
Ranked #23 by USN&WR...
Which is a good ranking.
UVA is the #1 state school in the country. Admissions is pretty competitive.
Re:Go Ahead, Let Your Kids Fail
by mathattack on Monday February 24, 2014 @09:53AM
(#7291055)
I think it's more a relative point. If you want to major in Philosophy/Art History/Religion and get a good job, only a small handful of schools matter, and UVa isn't one of them. UVa also isn't on the list of schools that NYC Upper East Side parents fight over. (I'm still happy to see it when a resume crosses my desk though)
Re:Go Ahead, Let Your Kids Fail
by mark_l_watson on Sunday February 23, 2014 @10:14AM
(#7286090)
I think credentials do count. As an example, I have worked with many people who have studied at MIT. They have all been very effective. I now find myself with a strong positive bias towards MIT grads.
That said, someone I used to babysit when I was a teenager dropped out of college and sold his last software company for over $300M, and this was about twelve years ago when three hundred million dollars was real money :-)
I bet its extremely rare for a person to both be very well credentialed and also very successful in their field (where the field does not explicitly depend on credentials--the Supreme Court is a counterexample).