News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Project Tango by discostrings on Thursday February 20, 2014 @04:21PM (#7273691)
> All your doing is slippery sloping your way into a cynical Utopian future which exists only within your own psyche. Your comment reeks of paranoia and baseless conspiratorial fear. If all you can think of in relation to the uses of cool and new technology is someone taking advantage of you than this is most likely the wrong industry to be participating in.

What you label as "paranoia" and "baseless conspiratorial fear" is better described as "examining the potential consequences of the things we build". You are advocating that we examine only the positive potential uses of the technology we develop and that we ignore the potential consequences, because "we'll work it out and everything will be awesome!", or something.

Perhaps the potential consequences will never come to fruition--but it's still very important that we examine them. There's a real shortage of that going on, which is why some people post negative reactions to these developments rather than something more balanced. Stop trying to dismiss those concerns and that conversation--if you're not interested in hearing it or taking part in it, this is likely the wrong discussion forum for you to be participating in.

Re:Project Tango by mempko on Thursday February 20, 2014 @04:12PM (#7273634)
It isn't paranoia if they are actually watching you.
[deleted]
Re:Project Tango by yazaddaruvala on Thursday February 20, 2014 @05:01PM (#7273973)
The problem is also that, "watching you" is a bad analogy. It implies, like you mention, that the entity has to prioritize who/what they "watch". This is a bad analogy because unlike humans, who can't watch historic events and therefore can only speculate at them (not held up in court), these entities can look back with a high degree of accuracy.

The problem, is no longer that someone is "watching you". Its worse. The problem is that someone, one day, could watch your entire life. Then proceed to pull apart events and use them, mostly out of context, against you.

I wouldn't call myself paranoid. I'm not doing anything about it. Honestly, if the data was only retained a month, unless needed in a current investigation, I would agree with you, this wouldn't be worth mentioning. However, retention of data is cheap and the data of your life will probably outlast you. As such, the parent posters in this convo have a point, it is something worth giving attention to.

PS. And to be quite honest, I don't even care that they can look back at my life and scrutinize me for an email or two. The real fear is that they can pull specific quotes or life choices out of context. You as an individual can't even discredit them because you don't have access to the original files (unless the entity does you a favor and shares them with you). So you can show how innocent the same email quote or life choice is while in context. You are instead left with your memory, and hopefully powerful rhetoric to convince a jury you are innocent.

Re:Project Tango by pyrocat on Thursday February 20, 2014 @04:18PM (#7273674)
I think you meant dystopian. And those are all logical conclusions, based on the information we've learned in the last 8 months.
Re:Project Tango by T-A on Thursday February 20, 2014 @04:21PM (#7273694)
Except Google sold SketchUp back in 2012: http://techland.time.com/2012/04/26/google-sells-sketchup-wa...