Re:Why is broadband more expensive in the US?
by rmc on Thursday February 20, 2014 @10:05AM
(#7271051)
(often unionized) U.S. workers
Some of the countries on that list (like France) have considerably more unionization and labour law than the USA
Re:Why is broadband more expensive in the US?
by bestdayever on Thursday February 20, 2014 @10:06AM
(#7271056)
US ISPs regularly get government subsidies. Hell they took 200 billion to start building fiber in 1996, then they didn't do it.
Re:Why is broadband more expensive in the US?
by rayiner on Thursday February 20, 2014 @10:13AM
(#7271098)
First, the $200 billion number is a total fabrication. It was derived by projecting how much more profit telecoms made after deregulation in 1996 than they would have had as tightly-regulated utilities. It's not money actually invested. The states never had that kind of money to invest.
Second, to the extent that tax breaks, etc, were handed out, it wasn't combined with the kind of political will you see in European countries or Asian countries. In South Korea, wiring Seoul up with fiber is a politically tractable proposal. In the U.S., wiring New York and Chicago and LA up with fiber is a political non-starter. In the U.S., rural votes count about 2x as much as urban votes, so to the extent that broadband appears on the political radar, it's all about making sure people in rural Kentucky can get DSL, not making sure people in major cities can get fiber.
1) It's well-known that U.S. providers achieve closer to advertised speeds than European providers. That's why the U.S. does way better in Akamai's tests of actual bandwidth than the OECD's study involving advertised bandwidth. The U.S. is currently 8th for highest average internet speed in Akamai's most recent state of the internet: http://www.akamai.com/dl/akamai/akamai-soti-q313.pdf?WT.mc_i... (see page 13).
2) It's not adjusted for price level in each country. Many things are cheaper in Hungary or Slovenia than the U.S. Internet service isn't a commodity good like an iPhone where everything is assembled in China. Internet infrastructure is put down and maintained by (often unionized) U.S. workers earning U.S. wages, and sold to customers also earning U.S. wages.
3) It ignores the cost of government subsidies: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/12/the-broadband-gap-w... ("There are only a handful of major projects worldwide to build fiber lines to homes that don’t involve significant government aid of some sort, Mr. Burstein said, including Verizon’s FiOS and Iliad’s fiber network in some large French cities.").