Re:Aereo loses copyright fight, gets banned in 6 states
by rayiner on Thursday February 20, 2014 @09:18AM
(#7270807)
Technical sophistication has nothing to do with this. Aereo's technology isn't complicated, or innovative, in a way courts have trouble understanding. It's a fairly low-tech workaround for rules that draw an otherwise easy to understand line between over the air broadcasts and streaming. The argument Aereo is making isn't a technical one, it's a nitpicky lawyer-ly loophole-y one. It's clearly a streaming service, but because there's a physical antenna involved, it shouldn't be subject to the same rules as other streaming services?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Aereo loses copyright fight, gets banned in 6 states
by ChuckMcM on Thursday February 20, 2014 @06:38PM
(#7274443)
Ray its more sophistication with the meaning of the technology as it applies to the law versus the law itself. The Google v Oracle trial gave us some good examples of what 'understanding' looks like in the judiciary, specifically in understanding that you have to use the same name for a Java method if you want to be "compatible" (widely protected as fair use) even though the words/characters are identical which looks like written text.