News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Buying WhatsApp for $16B in Cash and Stock Plus ... by erikpukinskis on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @06:38PM (#7267468)
I think the number of active users is what makes this comparison invalid. At the time of AOL's acquisition of ICQ it had 20 million active users¹. WhatsApp has 430 million. In order to eclipse WhatsApp, a competitor would have to get substantially more than 10% of the entire global population.

ICQ was dominant in its heyday, but the game wasn't won yet, so it was theirs to lose. In some sense that's still true: we have another 4 billion people yet to join the game. But we're nearing the endgame and as we get closer to the "everyone already has a good messaging solution" line it's going to get harder and harder for an upstart to come in and eat everyone's lunch.

¹ http://ec.europa.eu/competition/mergers/cases/decisions/m184...

Re:Facebook Buying WhatsApp for $16B in Cash and Stock Plus ... by trhway on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:14PM (#7267728)
>In some sense that's still true: we have another 4 billion people yet to join the game.

and tens of billions of various sensors, smart toasters/cars/milk cartons ... after that

Re:Facebook Buying WhatsApp for $16B in Cash and Stock Plus ... by orbifold on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:11PM (#7267705)
I agree, but there are still a few things Whatsapp lacks, in particular convenient end-to-end encryption that might not be feature for the mass market, but is probably interesting for enterprises.
Re:Facebook Buying WhatsApp for $16B in Cash and Stock Plus ... by nousernamesleft on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @07:42PM (#7267894)
Except the number of active users reinforces his point, it doesn't make it invalid.

>At the time of AOL's acquisition of ICQ it had 20 million active users¹

Or 40% of the internet using population of the world.

>WhatsApp has 430 million

Or 16% of the internet using population of the world.

40% is clearly closer to "won" than 16% is.

Re:Facebook Buying WhatsApp for $16B in Cash and Stock Plus ... by erikpukinskis on Thursday February 20, 2014 @01:36AM (#7269264)
> 40% is clearly closer to "won" than 16% is.

No, because the internet was expanding rapidly, so it wasn't won at all. That's like saying a basketball game is won because one of the teams got 100% of the points awarded in the first minute.

My point is that as "number of happy messaging users" approaches "number of humans" things will get harder and harder for a messaging upstart. Whoever I was responding to was suggesting that there will just be a long chain of succession forever and ever. I'm saying I think surpassing the encumbants was easy five years ago, is still doable today, but will be quite hard in 20 years.