And yes, the whole question is to ask to what extent we can trust this. Personally, it's just as likely that a human proof would have a subtle and hard-to-find error, missed by all the reviewers.
All the popular articles are claiming this humungous output is a proof. It's not a proof, it's a certificate from a SAT solver. There's a difference, and most comments people are making based on the popular accounts are misguided.
The negative witness, that is, the DRUP unsatisfiability certificate, is probably one of longest proofs of a non-trivial mathematical result ever produced. Its gigantic size is comparable, for example, with the size of the whole Wikipedia, so one may have doubts about to which degree this can be accepted as a proof of a mathematical statement.
I also suspect we're mostly in complete agreement.
You could just run the program and verify that the certificates match a few times, I guess you can't be 100% certain but the probability of a bit flip happening multiple times is extremely small.
Hmm. Are bit flips from cosmic rays more likely than a human making a mistake verifying a proof, or even a large number of humans making the same mistake?