We have commercial experience (well, at least in Russia) making communications towers a mile or so tall. Making one five miles tall would not be a huge stretch of the imagination, and those are fairly tolerant of all kinds of ridiculous abuse. Simply attach the elevator at the top of the tower instead of ground level and you've eliminate pretty much any man-portable non nuke attack potential and most mechanized vehicle attacks (or accidents).
Ditto the elevator material. We can't afford for weight reasons to make the entire thing "airliner proof" but we can afford to make the bottom 10 miles or so "small cessna proof". So make the bottom couple miles quadruple redundant steel battleship anchor chain or whatever. 99% of it will still have to be light as a feather, but nothing can hit it, so thats OK.
Yes, but the actual continuous power delivered by it would be surprisingly low, making it pointless.
> And, would stopping lightning cause other problems for Earth?
No, as the effect would be very localized.
What about lightning though? When a cloud contains an imbalance of electrons, won't the lightning strike much rather travel through the cable and weaken the material so it breaks?