Re:First animals may have lived with almost no oxygen
by rflrob on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:11PM
(#7261088)
This is not at all what I study, but it seems possible to me that sponges have evolved a tolerance for low oxygen conditions in the billion or so years since they first arose. It's a common mistake to think that because something is morphologically very similar to an ancient form (a so called "living fossil"), that it hasn't undergone any evolution. As long as it has been reproducing and mutating, better adapted versions have always had differential success, hence they've evolved, even if the shape hasn't changed.
Re:First animals may have lived with almost no oxygen
by chc on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @04:23PM
(#7261171)
I thought the point of the study was that these sponges live in an oxygen-rich environment, so there is no pressure for them to develop this trait in the modern world. It doesn't prove it's a primitive trait, but it at least makes it unlikely that it's a recent adaptation.
Re:First animals may have lived with almost no oxygen
by thotpoizn on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @09:32PM
(#7261478)
Is the "oxygen-rich environment" universally true, though? It's not as though oxygen saturation in the ocean is perfectly homogeneous. There are plenty of naturally occurring areas of hypoxia, and one could easily imagine an adaptation which allowed better survival in or near these "dead zones" could be quite useful, at least to localized populations. Is there some obvious reason that dramatically reduces the likelihood that one or more pockets of sponges might have capitalized on such a mutation more recently?
Re:First animals may have lived with almost no oxygen
by xherberta on Wednesday February 19, 2014 @09:04AM
(#7263638)
I tuned out when they started dating the emergence of a group of animals by working backwards based on a guess of how long they would have needed to achieve a certain level of genetic diversity.
That's interesting as conjecture, and I'll take it as such.
Re:First animals may have lived with almost no oxygen
by marcosdumay on Tuesday February 18, 2014 @09:22PM
(#7261456)
That's not about early life. It's about early animals, that only came to be much, much later than the former, when oxygen was already plenty at the atmosphere.
It's not a completely novel idea, but it it an interesting find which may lead to more interesting conclusions.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_catastrophe