Re:BelKor has allegedly won Netflix Prize despite being seco...
by davidw on Monday July 27, 2009 @10:45AM
(#725917)
> clearly not zero sum
Ok, so call it "fixed sum" or whatever else is technically correct - that's the point I'm trying to make. If one guy wins, another guy necessarily loses. That's not true in plenty of other things.
> the more skilled you are the more likely you are to win
Yes, but the second and third guys are quite skilled too, and win nothing (and yes, we are excluding the externalities since we're talking about the general case, not this specific one).
Ok, so call it "fixed sum" or whatever else is technically correct - that's the point I'm trying to make. If one guy wins, another guy necessarily loses. That's not true in plenty of other things.
> the more skilled you are the more likely you are to win
Yes, but the second and third guys are quite skilled too, and win nothing (and yes, we are excluding the externalities since we're talking about the general case, not this specific one).