News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by birken on Saturday February 15, 2014 @01:50PM (#7244790)
I think you are mixing up a correlation vs causation effect.

The first thing is there is an extremely important causation effect, the more investors you have, the easier it is to get more people to invest (social proof).

So, inbound vs outbound:

If you have a lot more investors already committed, you have a lot more social proof. Naturally if you have more investors, you will have a lot investors talking about your deal to other investors. Thus, the people who contact you inbound want to invest. However, it has nothing to do with the fact that they are inbound, it is just that by the time they are contacting you, your fundraising already was dripping with social proof.

Conversely, at the beginning when you have no investors, you likely are going to have to contact some of them. This is obviously going to have a much lower conversion rate, because you have no social proof!

Taken to the logical extreme, if inbound investors are so much more valuable than outbound, when you start fundraising you should just sit next to your telephone and wait for investors to call you. But of course that won't work, because it isn't inbound investors that actually matter. It is all about building social proof, and then once you have that, a lot of good things are going to happen. For example, YC is very powerful indication of social proof, and look how much easier fundraising became!

Basically, people who read this TC article: if you are interested in fundraising, PG wrote the canonical piece about it, http://paulgraham.com/fr.html

This post is fun, and I congratulate you on raising your round, but this data isn't predictive or useful.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by michaelochurch on Saturday February 15, 2014 @02:01PM (#7244844)
This post is fun, and I congratulate you on raising your round, but this data isn't predictive or useful.

Yeah, "get inbound investor attention" is the worst advice ever; by definition, it's impossible. Trying to make people like you tends to have the opposite effect. It's like telling an awkward 17-year-old that he'll solve all his problems with women if he gets laid by a supermodel.

The fatalism is important. I'm glad that someone on the inside has the courage to point it out. The extremely low rate of success for outbound traffic, especially pre-YC, confirms the fatalistic view of the Valley that is, IMO, the right one. If you're born into connections, you're solid. If you have enough before-age-of-carefulness dirt on important people while at Stanford and got in The Club, you'll never have to raise money; you'll be in the position to turn it away. If you're anyone else, though, the best advice regarding SillyCon Valley is just to sit this lifetime out, because the factors that matter most are those you can't do anything about.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by nostrademons on Saturday February 15, 2014 @04:06PM (#7245316)
Y'know what's universally unattractive to both investors and women? Fatalism.

People want to see how well you play the cards that you're dealt. If you can make something happen starting from nothing, then they figure that once they give you some cards to play with, you'll do even better from that. If you can't make something happen with limited resources, what makes you think that more resources will magically fix things?

This applies to a lot of other things as well - most of the time, when you start at a new job you have to start small, because people who control the resources want to see that you can work effectively on a small project before they give you a big mission-critical project. I've seen people get hired into Google at T4 (nowadays, virtually everybody is hired into T4 or below) and then work their way up to T9 because every time they're given a more ambitious challenge they master it in short order.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by rahimnathwani on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:18PM (#7246510)
Can you translate T4 and T9 into something a non-Googler can understand? Maybe to what would be on that person's business card?
Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by nostrademons on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:36PM (#7246667)
T4 = Software Engineer III, T9 = Distinguished Engineer. I'm not sure if other places have Distinguished Engineer titles, but it's basically the engineering ladder equivalent of a high-level eng Director or low-level VP, supposedly "People who have made critical contributions to Google or industry-changing software developments." Basically Jeff Dean level post-Bigtable.
Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by mindcrime on Saturday February 15, 2014 @02:22PM (#7244936)
; you'll be in the position to turn it away. If you're anyone else, though, the best advice regarding SillyCon Valley is just to sit this lifetime out, because the factors that matter most are those you can't do anything about.

Or just start building your company without anybody else's money at all, or money raised outside of SV... and then become, as they say, "so good they can't ignore you." At the end of the day, these people are pragmatic... get enough traction and I'm pretty sure the "in the club or not" distinction disappears in the wash.

Of course, the best scenario is one where you never wind up needing VC money at all, whether it's from the Valley or elsewhere. But that might not work for everybody. Still, you can start without those guys in most industries, especially if you can code and are building a software product.

Obviously if you're doing a pharma play or something with huge initial capital costs, the equation changes, but I doubt the majority of this audience (HN readers) are founding pharmaceutical companies...

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by timmm on Sunday February 16, 2014 @01:11AM (#7246822)
This.

Isn't part of the appeal of starting a web business the low costs required to do so? It sure as hell was for me when I started out.

I have an app that I go months without doing anything with (touching the code base, answering customers, ect.) and yet it still earns me a constant flow of income. In other words my profit margins are absurd (>90%). That's pretty cool if you ask me.

Of course I won't be earning millions from it but I earn enough money and I maintain full autonomy. I frequent places like hacker-news to learn things and to stay connected with the community but I have absolutely no interest networking with investors or taking money from an seed/accelerator firm.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by soundlab on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:32AM (#7247872)
Couldn't agree more. Step 1 toward this is to completely eradicate any VC/startup investor blogs or threads from your browser and substitute them with real daily communications with potential customers.

I look at the entire VC model and see it as a huge waste of most entrepreneurs' time and energy. Why entrepreneurs seek validation from accelerators, investors, and the media is beyond me. The usual response is that to build an enormous company at a very high growth rate requires a ton of money and doing anything other than that is mailing it in infamous lifestyle business approach. I reject that entire premise- you can make quite a large dent in the world, build a large business, and generate a big income by bootstrapping in one niche market after another- the major tradeoff is time.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by edanm on Saturday February 15, 2014 @04:46PM (#7245484)
"Trying to make people like you tends to have the opposite effect. It's like telling an awkward 17-year-old that he'll solve all his problems with women if he gets laid by a supermodel."

That's a terrible worldview. Trying to get people to like you does not tend to have the opposite effect, at least not when coupled with actual, real steps in learning how to get people to like you.

Say what you want about things like Pick Up Artists, etc., but they are effective. There is a world of advice one can give to an awkward 17-year-old that will actually help them.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by timmm on Sunday February 16, 2014 @12:57AM (#7246799)
> If you're anyone else, though, the best advice regarding SillyCon Valley is just to sit this lifetime out

Or you can opt out of the silicon valley game of what is essentially arbitrage and instead grow a tech company the proper way which is by bootstrapping and eventually accumulate enough profit to have that aspect of your life sorted out. And you will have done it without all the headaches and bullshit that comes along with investors.

Re:Was Y Combinator Worth It? by ChuckMcM on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:13PM (#7245130)
I wonder if you can use it as an inverse signal, which is if no one is calling you then your not visible enough? Or some other issue that might need to be addressed?