News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:04AM (#724455)
I don't see anything different in this respect in China than I do in many western societies. Having a leg up is definitely a pre, anywhere. It may differ in degree but certainly not in principle.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by rdouble on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:14AM (#724463)
In which western countries are 90% of the billionaires children of government officials?
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:17AM (#724466)
errm... I said 'degree' didn't I ?

I meant that in any society the number of people that will make it big that have connections will outnumber those that do not.

It's very hard to 'make it on your own', in any society and China is (unsurprisingly) no exception.

News would have been 90% of Chinese billionaires (or millionaires or some other metric) had no family or other connection to power.

On another note, there are only 9 Chinese billionaires in all (10 if you count HK); see http://www.forbes.com/lists/2007/10/07billionaires_The-World...

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by rdouble on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:23AM (#724472)
The news was 90% of Chinese billionaires are actually kids of government officials. That would be like if the billionaires in the UK were children of parliamentary officials or if the billionaires in the USA were children of senators and representatives. It's wrong to equivocate the Chinese situation with simply having "connections." It's a fundamental structural difference between China and "western societies."

Also, what you're implying in the weak sense is probably wrong. Billionaire lists are easily found on the internet and if you look at the bios of the people on such lists, I would assert the opposite - most of the billionaires in western countries started out with few significant connections at all.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:34AM (#724482)
Gates: son of a lawyer, Buffet: son of a politician, Slim: son of a real estate broker and so on...

Connections help. In a totalitarian society they help more.

The only thing that stops the situation from being much worse is term limits.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by nostrademons on Sunday July 26, 2009 @03:00PM (#724732)
There's a difference in degree here too though: there's a massive difference between "son of a lawyer" and "son of a central committee member". Gates is considered one of the more privileged billionaires, because his mother was on the board of directors for United Way and his father was a prominent lawyer. That seems like a crack down from his parents being President or in the Cabinet.

It also ignores counterexamples like Steve Jobs (from a working class, blue collar family), Larry Ellison (Jewish immigrants who worked as modest government employees) or Larry Page and Sergey Brin (children of professors).

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by maigret on Sunday July 26, 2009 @04:28PM (#724849)
Hm well professor is not exactly middle class either... Actually children of professors are probably the best prepared to make a great career more than anyone else. Parents with connections, lots of knowledge and more time than people working in the industry - that's the perfect mix. I know a few sons of professors, they just surf through life.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by zandorg on Sunday July 26, 2009 @06:32PM (#724976)
But even so, being a Professor is earned by hard academic work, and not connections.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by dimitar on Monday July 27, 2009 @03:31AM (#725546)
Being a son/daughter of a Professor isn't earned.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by rdouble on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:39AM (#724487)
Buffet's father wasn't a politician until after Buffet was rich. If anything, in western countries it's easier to become a government official because you're related to someone rich than it is to get rich because you're the kid of a government official.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:46AM (#724499)
No he wasn't, from the wikipedia article on Warren Buffet:

"After his father was elected to Congress, Buffett was educated at Woodrow Wilson High School"

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by rdouble on Sunday July 26, 2009 @11:49AM (#724502)
Whoops, I got my dates wrong. I concede - you win.
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by omail on Sunday July 26, 2009 @12:06PM (#724517)
I count 16,

Chinese citizenship: Wong Kwong Yu, Zhang Li, Zhang Jindong, Chu Mang Yee, Zhang Cheng Fei, Guo Guangchang, Liu Yongxing, Xu Jiayin, Liu Yonghao, Lu Guanqiu, William Ding, Zong Qinghou, Li Wei, Song Weiping, Liang Wengen, Chen Fashu

Hong Kong: Li Sze Lim

Australia: Shi Zhengrong

USA: Roger Wang

Nineteen if you count these other guys. All reside in China.

Interestingly enough, this list does not include the people listed at the bottom of the article: Hu Haifeng, Winston Wen Yunsong, Jiang Mianheng, Li Xiaopeng, and Levin Zhu.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by joe_the_user on Sunday July 26, 2009 @04:22PM (#724840)
One interesting thing about the article is pointed to a specific, one-way path. Sons of high government official became wealthy entrepreneurs. They didn't and apparently couldn't become high government officials themselves. Their offspring perhaps also cannot become high official. Moroever, they will eventually have to compete with the sons of new high officials, since the high officials themselves are apparently drawn from all over.

An interesting trend and perhaps more interesting than just the simple concentration of power - though power often likes to concentrate.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by DanielBMarkham on Sunday July 26, 2009 @12:46PM (#724556)
I didn't mod you down, but I read you plea for critiques and am happy to give you one.

"Getting a leg up" is a broad phrase that could mean anything from knowing people at the local country club to paying off government officials for special treatment.

In western societies, the idea is that governments change on a regular basis. This prevents, in theory, high-ranking government officials from getting into bed on a permanent basis with companies. Note that corruption doesn't magically go away: what probably happens is that you trade off one set of crooks for another. But -- and this is a very important but -- it changes.

Some types of getting a leg up are certainly fine. Some aren't. It's a really important distinction to make, because it lets some systems flex and adapt and leaves others incapable of it.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @12:51PM (#724567)
I think the common element is that the people around you are the key to your lot in life. In western societies that is being born into some money or knowing people that have some, in China it means the party.

Neither of those are a guarantee, but statistically speaking you'd expect people with connections or with parents in high places to do better than those without.

Rags-to-riches stories exist, but for every pauper that 'made it' there are hundreds if not thousands or more that don't stand a chance.

In a fair society everybody has equal chances at birth, but such a society does not exist (or at least I'm not aware of one). China is 'unfair' because it apparently gives the children of the party bosses extreme advantages, the west is unfair because if your parents have money you're likely to leverage that.

Oh, and I absolutely agree that this is the kind of 'leg up' that should be illegal, it's cronyism pure and simple. But then again, so is the 'Bush dynasty'. Or is there a gene for politics ?

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by DanielBMarkham on Sunday July 26, 2009 @01:05PM (#724575)
That's the common element, sure. And we see this everywhere, no matter what the political system.

Some of the stats on wealth creation are interesting. If I remember correctly, it's very unusual for children of rich people to also generate a lot of wealth on their own. That's why you see one rich guy trying his best to keep his kids from squandering everything. If you're lucky you send them to a lot of schooling and they do acceptably well.

It's the hustlers that make the money, no matter the system.

I don't think you can have "fair" -- it's an overloaded term and can be stretched to fit anything. What you can have is enough controlled chaos and change that patterns are not easy to spot and exploit.

I'm not familiar with the term "Bush dynasty". Do you mean the fact that a bunch of them are in politics? If so, you'd have to add the Gores, the Kennedys. and a lot more to that category. I'm concerned that we're creating a system of nobility here with all of the offices that effectively have no competition and all of the families that hand down political power, but that seems a little off-topic for this thread.

I wouldn't say China is unfair because children of bosses get the goodies. I would say China is unstable because the same bosses rule for generations and the same kids get the same handouts. We see this pattern in a lot of places, but China has it the worst.

It's just the type of thing that Chinese communism was supposed to stop from having, so if anything you'd think they would be sensitive to this.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by vidarh on Sunday July 26, 2009 @04:44PM (#724864)
> It's just the type of thing that Chinese communism was supposed to stop from having, so if anything you'd think they would be sensitive to this.

You're assuming the people in power in China are communists, which is a pretty big assumption.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @04:47PM (#724869)
I think they are as much 'believers' as religious leaders are 'believers'.

Self delusion goes a long way towards apologizing for taking a bit more than you're giving, especially when you don't respect those that you are taking from.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jhancock on Sunday July 26, 2009 @01:16PM (#724586)
In practice, I'm not sure that Chinese "incumbency rates" are too different from U.S. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_stagnation_in_the...

China has had major shifts in power about ever 10 to 20 years for the last 4 years. I don't think the U.S. is doing much better.

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by zandorg on Sunday July 26, 2009 @06:34PM (#724977)
You mean 40 years?
Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by jacquesm on Sunday July 26, 2009 @12:35PM (#724545)
To all those that feel the need to mod this down if you do not agree with me then feel free to write why you don't agree.

Do you think that having a leg up is somehow detrimental to your progress ? Is it a coincidence that people with connections (or party affiliations) have an easier time of amassing wealth in China ? Is that same coincidence at work when the son of a politician makes a fortune or becomes a politician himself in a western society ?

Re:90% of China's billionaires are kids of high-ranking offi... by psranga on Sunday July 26, 2009 @05:33PM (#724915)
This is impedence mismatch between you and the community.

Your readings and experiences have caused you to form some opinions about how the world works (i.e., connections are very important), but most people here think that connections don't matter as much as you think.

I'm not that surprised that people here think that way since most of us here hope to make something brilliant and rock the world (and thereby make tons of money).

My two cents: In mature industries (e.g., telecom, entertainment, construction, banking, automobiles, healthcare, pharma) connections are almost the only thing that matters (both in China and in the US), but in dynamic sectors such as computers connections are much less important.