News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by mwfunk on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:21PM (#7241415)
It sounds like the author became a programmer many times over, but kept slamming into his own expectations about what the process would be like.

Learning any new language is a process of continuously diminishing returns- it feels like you're moving along in leaps and bounds at first, as everything you learn is applicable to almost every program someone might write in that language, and things that looked like gibberish before start to make sense. Eventually you move past the basics and get into more specialized, esoteric, and less generally-applicable bits, and it feels like it's taking a lot more effort to learn much smaller and less widely applicable chunks of information.

This isn't even taking into account the fact that the more you learn about something, the more aware you become of how much you don't know. Two months in, you might feel less confident in your knowledge base than you did after the first month. It's just the nature of the game.

I really got the sense reading this that the author assumed that the learning process would always be linear (the ratio of effort to returns wouldn't decay as he got deeper into it), and that eventually he would reach an endpoint where he just knew everything and could build whatever he could imagine without continuing to struggle and flounder. It's not like that though. You're never done learning, you never reach a point where you can whip up nontrivial projects without at least a little bit of floundering, and you never reach a point where most real-world projects you take on don't involve learning yet more new stuff or periods of floundering and frustration and false starts while you wrestle with how to design and implement it.

It sounds like he would get to this point of diminishing returns and assume that this must be happening because he wasn't cut out to be a programmer, but really the problem was that he was assuming that things would get easier, not harder.

It doesn't help that he was so focused on web development as opposed to other types of programming- more than any other programming specialty, web development involves grab bags of seemingly random and unrelated technologies, some vastly overengineered, some comically underengineered, and none of which were really designed to be used together in the ways that people want to use them.

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by phantom_oracle on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:53PM (#7241620)
> "It doesn't help that he was so focused on web development as opposed to other types of programming- more than any other programming specialty, web development involves grab bags of seemingly random and unrelated technologies, some vastly overengineered, some comically underengineered, and none of which were really designed to be used together in the ways that people want to use them."

Doesn't this lead to the simple fact that the way things are built in the browser is in 1 simple word: fucked?

A lot of the passion-based fanboys have justified the existence of at least 5 different mindsets needed to flesh out a single application (eg. some web app using: Ruby with Rails, JavaScript, HTML + CSS and lets throw in the need to write a couple of bash scripts just for petes sake).

I've long been contemplating having a single-language situation or at max 2 languages to flesh out web applications (why the fuck does CSS need to exist?).

If a browser itself could be built on a core of using just one language (like C++) then I don't see why stuff that works in a browser can't be done with that same philosophy.

So now I'll have to find myself a bomb shelter and spend the next 20 years writing a web-only language to solve the pain points of some dumb shit called JavaScript that is great because Node.js is great...

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by GregBuchholz on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:02AM (#7242737)
>So now I'll have to find myself a bomb shelter and spend the next 20 years writing a web-only language

Eliminate the entire browser and just start distributing x64 "apps" to raw hardware sandboxed virtual machines in Bochs or another emulator. That way people could have as much pixel level control for display purposes as they wanted. Ideally you'd also have some client side OCR so that we could copy and store text from these new websites. Some sites would want to have you download megabytes of "operating systems" before. But there'd be nothing stopping you from making a raw hardware Forth website 1000 times smaller than the next guy if you so desired

http://www.ultratechnology.com/forth.htm

You could bootstrap the whole thing by having bochs run in a asm.js setup, with the graphics frame buffer being spit out to a HTML5 canvas.

http://bellard.org/jslinux/

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by zem on Friday February 14, 2014 @10:09PM (#7242488)
you might like opa; at the very least it's worth a look. it bills itself as a "framework for javascript" but it's actually a language that lets you write frontend and back end code that mixes seamlessly

http://opalang.org

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by SomeCallMeTim on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:57PM (#7241637)
>You're never done learning, you never reach a point where you can whip up nontrivial projects without at least a little bit of floundering

I agree that you're never done learning, but you shouldn't "flounder" forever. Somewhere between 4 and 10 years you should be done floundering. :)

Sure you may need to check your API reference for specific function names and parameters, but there are very few aspects of my main languages that I don't just know without having to look them up at this point.

And that experience translates even to languages you haven't spent a lot of time learning. With less than a dozen hours of JavaScript exposure, I understood the syntax of his "OMG!" examples. It does eventually get easier.

It seems like he's giving up too soon, but he's also (seemingly) refusing to just ask questions. There must be forums where he could ask about syntax like that.

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by verisimilidude on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:32PM (#7241500)
I had the same reaction, especially when I got to his paragraph about Sinatra (vs. Ruby on Rails). If Sinatra is more fun for him, more easy for him to understand, and more productive for him, why not use it to build things? It's possible to build very nice things on top of simple tools like Sinatra.

To the author, I think you should give yourself a lot more credit.

Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by kenrikm on Friday February 14, 2014 @06:43PM (#7241876)
My takeaway was that the OP could not grasp MVC which caused all the issues with learning the frameworks. Also I'm a firm believer that you can't really learn unless you want to make something. If you're not trying to build a game/website/app that you're excited about then you're not going to go far.
Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by oxplot on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:20PM (#7250464)
I strongly agree with this point and wrote something about it a while back http://blog.oxplot.com/transient-ideas-and-learning/
Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by saltcod on Monday February 17, 2014 @02:51PM (#7254060)
fantastic post @oxplot! That chart of time vs motivation is unbelievably true.
Re:Throwing in the towel on becomming a programmer by kpennell on Friday February 21, 2014 @08:24AM (#7276810)
excellent post