Re:Gog.com giving away Dungeon Keeper for free
by prezjordan on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:06PM
(#7241328)
Great explanations, thanks. I think the biggest difference is that some games (like Dungeon Keeper Mobile IIRC) have IAP into perpetuity - meaning you can essentially never unlock the full game. I like your FTP client example, I'll be using that.
Games that have in-app purchases run the spectrum. Some use in-app purchases to do customizations and other fun things that don't affect gameplay. Then there are those like Dungeon Keeper which are basically unplayable without in-app purchases. Watch the video I linked above for details on why. You have to pay over and over and over just to keep the game playable.
This is very different from a shareware/free trial model. You pay ONE TIME and you own the whole game. It's a classic commercial game scenario except they give you a taste of it... a trial... for free. It's the same thing with 'lite' versions of commercial software that are also free.
The in-app purchasing model is more akin to getting a free version of an FTP client that only allowed you to upload software at 10KB/s. You can then pay $0.99 to upload that one file at full speed. But, your very next upload would again be 10KB/s unless you also paid $0.99 to upload that one at full speed. But wait, for an even better value, you can buy a 20-pack of full-speed uploads for only $9.99 or a 100-pack of full-speed uploads for only $29.99. Once those run out, of course, you're back to 10KB/s. Unless you spend even more money.
Now, it seems silly with the FTP client example above. Who would ever use that software? But this is exactly how many of the free to play games work. And this is the way a lot of people coming in to gaming for the first time think games work.