Upstart is certainly not an example of NIH-syndrome. At the time that upstart was written, nothing else existed that solved the problems that it did. systemd did not exist at the time. Ubuntu led the way here, and it is unfair to claim otherwise.
Had launchd already been available under the Apache License 2.0 at the time, who knows, it might now be well-established on Linux. (AIUI, GPL compatibility is not an issue here — the problem is more the APSL isn't compatible with, e.g., the Debian Free Software Guidelines (DFSG) and hence would never be adopted by the Linux community at large.)
(It can be, but that means it isn't working very well)
service ssh restart works fine but that was fine in sysvinit as well..
service my_service restart
required writing 100+ shell scripts, each of which was error prone and difficult.This happened to me once. Never again, damn it.
If their alternatives were better, or at least equivalent, it would not be so bad. But these NIH projects typically only have Canonical (and some Ubuntu) people working on them.
Go to Launchpad bugs and look through open and closed tickets. The NIH projects often cause Ubuntu user problems, and they just lay there and no one fixes them. If Debian, Red Hat, fd.o etc. had other distros depending on things, there would be a lot of people around to fix problems. When Ubuntu does it's own version, they are usually the people who have to fix problems.
Well, this was a pleasant surprise.
I honestly thought that Ubuntu would continue to use Upstart regardless of what Debian decided. It'd have been a monumental amount of work to take on, but on the other hand, there's already been a lot of NIH-syndrome in Ubuntu-land for a while (Upstart, Mir, Unity, etc.)
Ubuntu's been slowly moving in the direction of becoming a "silo", spearate from other Linux distributions for a while now (a direction I dislike). If Ubuntu had decided to double-down on Upstart against the tide, that would have been the final nail in the coffin for them (in my books - they'd still find success for at least a while no matter what they did).
EDIT: Upstart may actually not be a great example of NIH, but Mir certainly is.