News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by fulafel on Friday February 14, 2014 @08:35AM (#7238364)
First you say that this problem can't be helped by other countries and then you discuss the EU's eastward expansion... which is largeely about Western European countries getting together and lifting up ex-Soviet countries.

The terms under which those countries were allowed into the EU were largely about building strong anti-corruption measures and improving transparency in government.

Supernational institutions like the EU and UN can do great things like this.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by BugBrother on Friday February 14, 2014 @08:43AM (#7238413)
>>and then you discuss

Starting with "For examples of this".

>>Supernational institutions like the EU and UN can do great things like this.

Well, give me some examples where corruption of a political system was solved by external organisations?

(And NOT in a military way.)

(The main benefit East Europe got was a pressure to conform with EU criteria to get into the trade union. That solved quite a lot, by paying the political leadership to solve their problems... This can only be done once. But Romania and Bulgaria got into EU without fulfilling those criteria, probably by bribing for the EU votes (as I understand it, a few large companies were sold cheap to French, Belgian etc companies). So corruption worked for them... not even here, with a big carrot, was it solved by the EU!)

Edit: I might add that the UN is infamously corrupt and many functions are taken over by dictators, working for their combined interests. (If you're Swedish, you won't read about that in your local media.) Hardly able to help anyone with corruption...

Re:The Star Trek Economy by jotm on Saturday February 15, 2014 @04:15AM (#7243184)
Even Greece and Italy (with all of their history), still turned to corruption to benefit from the EU. Can't solve this problem by throwing more money at it from the outside.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by BugBrother on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:12AM (#7243437)
Uhm, are you really claiming those two countries weren't corrupt before the EU?! Afaik, both are classic cases of the Mediterranean client-patron culture? (At least the south of Italy.)

My original point was that to make a country a nice place today is not rocket science, the failures either seems to be an ongoing conflict -- or corruption.

Afaik the methods to stop corruption isn't that hard to design, the hard part is to get a political class to implement them. To do it from outside is impossible without an invasion, you have to get the population to pressure the criminal thieves (a.k.a. politicians).

(I guess 'fulafel' is a naive Swede who grew up believing his own media, like I did. That is why I bother with this.)

Disclaimer: No political science education, just a hobby to read to try to understand the world,

Re:The Star Trek Economy by jotm on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:12PM (#7246623)
I meant that they were corrupt, they hid everything from the EU, took their money without fixing much of anything, then the truth came out and shit hit the fan.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by BugBrother on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:03AM (#7247984)
Ah, yes. It seems this plague might be spread more by EU membership than it is cured. Not a positive future for Europe... :-(
Re:The Star Trek Economy by jotm on Sunday February 16, 2014 @12:06PM (#7248278)
I think it will work out fine if the members stick through for enough time. Kinda like the United States - the states have almost gone to war several times after the Civil War...