Re:America’s labour market has suffered permanent harm
by magicalist on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:56PM
(#7236796)
> Anyway, the long-term social effect was (from where I'm sitting) positive
The positive social effects of...the Reign of Terror? You might as well throw in the Holodomor, the Khmer Rouge's Killing Fields, The Great Leap Forward, etc etc etc as everything's much better now than it was then. Post hoc ergo propter hoc, amirite?
Re:America’s labour market has suffered permanent harm
by busterarm on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:09PM
(#7236846)
The entire modern era of our civilization lies in the shadow of the French Revolution. It accelerated the rise of republics and democracies and the spread of every modern political ideology of today. 'Déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen' is not only a fundamental document of the Revolution but also the first (Western?) document to define all rights of men to be universal; valid at all times and in every place and pertaining to human nature itself.
I think that's pretty damned positive.
Re:America’s labour market has suffered permanent harm
by magicalist on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:23PM
(#7236905)
> Déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen' is not only a fundamental document of the Revolution but also the first (Western?) document to define all rights of men to be universal
And it was published four years before the executions started in ernest. Even if it hadn't been: all revolutions cause birthing pains, but it is fallacious to argue the converse.
Lower-classes get fucked in greater numbers when there is any social turmoil. They are a proportionately larger group of people. I don't have any numbers to look at but I think it's pretty likely that more than 60% of the French population during the Revolution was working class or peasants...so proportionately they may have fared better, because you have to look at their numbers in the population, not the percentages from who was killed.
Anyway, the long-term social effect was (from where I'm sitting) positive.