Consider the following two developers. Who would you rather hire, and who will get hired under this system?
1. Developer completes the task, unfamiliar to them, in 2 hours, or
2. Developer completes the task, familiar to them, in 1.5 hours?
(Some Objective-C flavour: NSXMLParser is a more appropriate solution than the one described)
One reason I picked 90 minutes for my example is that I was imagining a hypothetical task, and I don't think you would/should be left sat at a task for 2 hours where 15 mins was expected. I hope that wouldn't happen.
The guy actually learned the tech in less than 2 hours under pressure in an unfamiliar environment. If you fail him for that, the message you are actually giving is "I don't care if you can learn, every minute count in my business and if you don't know something you are out."
A good candidate who had never seen RSS before might be better at that than someone who has spent their entire career processing RSS and never thinking about the details.
We're kidding ourselves if we believe that our dev work is "all-new algorithms, all the time." It's not.