Mountain View and Cupertino, at least, seem to behave relatively sanely. Santa Clara almost goes too far as an industry town.
At the core of it, these people have a xenophobic fear of change. They might be making noise about rent prices now, but if these companies tried to address this concern, the concerns would shift.
The problem is the Peninsula actually is boring, at least for single people who don't drive. I'd rather see SFBA tech contribute $10-20b on making the Peninsula an awesome place to live, rather than trying to fix SF's infrastructure and politics. Plus, there's money to be made doing it.
Imagine what the SF housing/policy landscape would look like if these companies double headcount over the next 5 years. What's happening with the buses will pale in comparison (and the worst part is the buses aren't even the issue, they're just visible).
1) Large voting bloc of employees
2) BATNA to getting their way: credible threat to move. Google can't credibly threaten to move out of SFBA, sadly, and Twitter couldn't credibly threaten to move to Brisbane (because, Brisbane is crap). If Twitter hadn't had crazy political connections, mid-market wouldn't have happened.
You don't get large amounts of power just by paying a lot of taxes or employing a lot of people; if there are big voting groups who dislike you, you're still screwed.
This is not necessarily true. Housing prices don't fall uniformly in an area as more units become available, so existing residents may still be displaced. Also, more people may move from elsewhere to fill the vacancies provided by new units, driving higher prices for new units and making an area unaffordable for existing residents.
This is true, but you need to consider the supply and demand for housing in aggregate. You also need to consider how one type of housing can substitute for another. Building luxury condos (for example) doesn't immediately help middle and lower-middle class renters. However, the condo could appeal to highly-paid software engineers who would have otherwise rented an expensive but basic. That reduces demand for basic apartments, which puts downward pressure on prices for those units. It's not the same effect as just building a bunch of basic apartments, but it still helps more than doing nothing.
> Also, more people may move from elsewhere to fill the vacancies provided by new units, driving higher prices for new units and making an area unaffordable for existing residents.
This doesn't really make any sense at all. You're saying that rising rents encourage people to move to move to SF. If anything, rising rents will tend to discourage people from moving to SF for a tech job. Sure, the salary is high, but why bother if you're going have less left over after paying rent?
Look, it's not valid to say that people are perfectly rational, uniform, black spheres. People make irrational decisions all the time. But nobody says to him/herself, "I'd like to move to New York next year because the cost of living is so high." Building more housing units will result in more people living in SF, but it will also reduce the cost of living in SF compared to--and this part is important--what it would have otherwise been.
This isn't for charity - the housing shortage isn't particularly pleasant for their employees either, as it makes everything scarcer/more expensive (parking, grocery, other cost of living).
Edit: A couple of references on housing: http://www.sfgate.com/opinion/openforum/article/How-San-Fran...