Re:Remember Smalltalk? (2008)
by gaius on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:49PM
(#7226377)
It's simple. Java was free, Smalltalk was $50,000/seat.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Gartner also had an active hand in killing Smalltalk in the enterprise.
CTOs would pay Gartner millions of dollars to have them confirm their bias to go 100% Java/Windows/IBM.
Not that ParcPlace did themselves any favors.
Re:Remember Smalltalk? (2008)
by mark_l_watson on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @02:40PM
(#7226750)
Basically correct, except for the price of $50K. In the early 1980s I had a Xerox Lisp Machine (cost about $25K with extra RAM). Xerox let me use a Smalltalk license for a while for evaluation - I forget the exact price, but it was about $5K.
Now, nearly all programming languages are free :-)
Pharo Smalltalk (based on Squeak) is very nice, and runs on Mac, Windows, or Linux box using very little resources.
I learnt Java in '95 and was getting paid for it in '96 - the option to become a Smalltalk developer simply never existed for me - you already had to be one, to get access to it! That it faded into irrelevance is completely unsurprising, where was the fresh blood supposed to come from?
Re:Remember Smalltalk? (2008)
by mark_l_watson on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:23PM
(#7228164)
I rode the Java wave early on also. A good ride.
Smalltalk is still used, as is Common Lisp, Scheme, etc. Just because languages are only used for < 1% of commercial projects does not mean that people skilled in their use shouldn't use them. My go-to languages right now are Clojure, Java, and JavaScript, but, I still like to code occasionally in Pharo Smalltalk (good online tutorials, BTW, if you want to play with Pharo).