News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by joe_the_user on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:39PM (#7215636)
Well, since you're "here"

Here's the question I'd want to ask: if the Facebook ad clicks are from click-farms but you don't pay for them, how did they get there?

One guess would be that click-farm people like stuff at random to "seem legitimate". Maybe Facebook itself incentivizes fake account to like stuff by not deleting fake accounts that behave "conveniently".

But that's just a guess, I've look for someone to do more research.

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by x0054 on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:27PM (#7215784)
Jesus, did you watch the video that's subject of the post, or are you just posting, since "you are here." This is exactly the information that the video covers, with animations, explanations, and even links to sources.
Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by wozniacki on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:47AM (#7216215)
I wish we are sufficiently close to a time, when automated comment-comprehending and comment-curating software - like browser extensions and plugins - are widely available, thanks to advances made in the areas of (textual) Deep Learning and (textual) Artificial Intelligence.

Perhaps then, clumsy comments like the one made by joe_the_user:

  One guess would be that click-farm people like stuff at
  random to "seem legitimate".
could be neatly redacted by the extension, without affecting the rest of the comment.

I surely hope so.

Some of the comments that surface to the top of the heap, are head-achingly dreadful.

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by SkyMarshal on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @10:55AM (#7218164)
Including this one, ironically. x0054 called out the problem, no need to pile on with nothing more of any particular value to add.
Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by wozniacki on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @06:16PM (#7221266)
My comment is less ironic than you might discern.

History is rife with far wilder inventions than the comment-curating 'contraption' that I describe, that have been conceived and crafted, drawing from a far smaller source of inspiration than the clumsy comment made by joe_the_user.

In all probability, the sort of thing, I describe, would never materialize in the foreseeable future. It could just be a figment of my imagination.

The leaps and bounds that are required for such comment-comprehension - especially the two step thing needed for the software to assimilate the contents of the video and then contextually-observe that joe_the_user has not viewed the video, just by reading his comment - are probably far too great for the current state of Deep Learning and AI (someone well versed in these areas could chime in).

Or perhaps such advents in content curation - unbeknownst to us - are already afoot.

Surely then your quick dismissing of my "value-less" comment could be the butt of jokes for posterity.

Time will decide.

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by SkyMarshal on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @01:39AM (#7222920)
You're writing a lot of words without actually saying anything. You can try and dress your original comment up all you want, but all you were doing was kicking someone while they were down to make yourself feel superior, while attempting to disguise it in the form of some highbrow but vague speculation of some future technology without providing anything of concrete value about it. This is HN, we're all aware of the possibilities of strong AI, but unless you've got a github account with a demo in it or some new algorithm, you're just spouting bs.
Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by Anderkent on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:13AM (#7223692)
(Also, you really don't want to end the world just to get better hn comment threads. Strong AI is scary, man)
Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by interpares on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @12:55AM (#7216039)
The idea floated in this earlier Next Web article cited in the video is that click-farmers make use of the Page Suggestion feature, i.e. each time they like a Page FB suggests a new page they might also like to "like". What was once a useful service for discovery for legit users may have turned into the click-farmers' best friend.

http://thenextweb.com/facebook/2014/01/23/likes-lies-perfect...

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by lstamour on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:00PM (#7215713)
The parent comment author is not the original video author, given his appreciative comments for the video. (Not sure otherwise what you meant by 'Well, since you're "here"')

As to your question, that's exactly what the video covers. With a nice animation and everything. And really, I expect Facebook to post some useful numbers rather than forcing us to do the research.

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by AYBABTME on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @01:31AM (#7216160)
My understanding was that identifying fake accounts automatically was a pretty hard problem to solve. That's not making up for the likes being fake, but it does justify why they can't just delete all the fake accounts.

To me, it seems clear that if something's going on, it's not Facebook "conveniently" letting the fakes go. It's more the problem being hard to cope with.

Or somebody present me results that demonstrate how easy it is to identify fakes with low false positives.

Re:Facebook Fraud [video] by notlisted on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @08:24AM (#7217460)
As others pointed out I'm not the author of this wonderful video.