News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by Derbasti on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:09PM (#7214459)
What's wrong with "second"?
Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by brudgers on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:31PM (#7214552)
Nothing and Common Lisp includes second. But that's not caar. It returns the first element of the first element of a list - the extended forms of car and cdr are for nested lists and nested lists can be used to implement many different data structures [and are also the data structure containing Lisp programs].

The extended forms of car and cdr provide a form of expression which is not obvious based on the construction of common non-Lisp languages even those that have very flexible lists and dynamic typing.

Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by Derbasti on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @02:08AM (#7216281)
I know, so do (head (second list)), or if you must, (head2 list) or even (head list 2) or something. Still much more readable than cadr
Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:19PM (#7214503)
I presume you mean as opposed to "rest".

The problem is, it really is "rest" instead of "second", at least in the usual case. Yes, a cons cell can contain pretty much any two things, but the most-frequently-used case (or so I believe) is that of a list. In that case, "car" means "first element of the list", and "cdr" means "the entire rest of the list", not "the second element of the list".

Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by frou_dh on Monday February 10, 2014 @08:08PM (#7214997)
Personally I have found it useful to keep in mind that it's the pair that's fundamental and not the list. IIRC it was pg that made the point somewhere that car and cdr are acceptable because there really aren't any slam-dunk general terms for the parts of a pair.
Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by AnimalMuppet on Monday February 10, 2014 @08:43PM (#7215139)
True, and if you're thinking of them as a pair, then "first" and "second" are appropriate. But if you're using them to implement a list, then "second" is misleading.
Re:Common Lisp in the 21st Century by frou_dh on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:26PM (#7215588)
I'd probably go with "left" and "right" to get away from the implication of priority. I didn't type this using my first and second hands.

(bikeshedding acknowledged)