Re:Streams in Java 8
by pron on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:33PM
(#7208288)
Because then you'd only have Stream<T>; IntStream would be just Stream<int>. The problem with reified generics is that they bake a particular type system into the runtime. While once a desired feature, I don't think the wide JVM community wants that any more.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
To be fair, I don't think this is a problem with reified generics. The problem is that primitives cannot be erased to Objects in Java. Stream<int> only works in C# because int is an alias of Int32. Not because of reified generics.
The above should no longer be an issue when/if we remove the primitive types in Java 10(?) as we can safely use Stream<Integer> and Predicate<Integer> (or Stream<int>).
The runtime type erasure would have to be quite clever to realize that a ArrayList<Integer> should be backed by a primitive array of ints? One alternative is to erase ArrayList<T> into all variants (One for objects and one for each primitive type).
(In C# System.Int32 is a value type, and an "int" is equivalent). A List<Int32> is equivalent to a List<int> and is backed by an array of ints.)