News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by Tichy on Thursday July 23, 2009 @03:55PM (#720219)
Last time I looked almost all non-Mac high-end PCs suffered from "Klavierlack"-Syndrome. I don't know how it translates into english, but it is that cheesy shiny coating.

There are competitors who can create good high end PCs, but at the moment they suffer from a severe case of bad taste. Maybe most producers being Asian doesn't help either - nothing against them, just the tastes seem to be different.

Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by papersmith on Thursday July 23, 2009 @04:52PM (#720337)
Being Asian myself, I concur that we tend to have questionable tastes. It probably has something to do with the cultures going through an identity crisis.

This is most pronounced in car designs. Japanese and Korean cars designs generally look like they are "trying too hard", especially in the recent years in their high-end models. Maybe they are going for the funky-factor of the ricers, I don't know. British, Italian, and French cars usually look the least desperate. German and American cars are somewhere in the middle. Just my opinion.

Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by plinkplonk on Friday July 24, 2009 @06:18AM (#721231)
"Being Asian myself, I concur that we tend to have questionable tastes. "

Being Asian myself, I concur we have different tastes. ;-)

Most Asian cultures(Japanese, Indian etc)have their own aesthetic sensibilities. I concur that they are different from the "default" western sense of style. I just don't think it is true Asians have "questionable" taste!

NB: I am not getting into culture wars etc or claiming victimization etc, I just think that sentence is not true.

Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by papersmith on Monday July 27, 2009 @07:56PM (#727064)
I probably should've written a disclaimer as to indicate my opinion. :)

To be more specific, perhaps I should've emphasized that "modern" Asian cultures have questionable tastes, which is in direct contrast to traditional Asian sensibilities. I feel that modern Asian cultures are too busy imitating what's trendy in the west. It doesn't help the fact that instability of the past century made people lose faith in their indigineous cultures, while the western culture has evolved quite a bit since to adapt to changes of the world, thus leaving a big gap to catch up.

I'd venture that the vast portion of the old Asian cultures are appreciated now-a-days merely for their exotic aspects, even by Asian people themselves. Whatever is preserved for practical reasons don't always fit in a coherent manner, there are plenty of rough edges to work out.

I guess a bad analogy would be that Asian culture is like Unix, Apple is Europe, Windows is USA, China is BSD, and Japan is Ubuntu. The kernel is the philosophy, command line is the traditional culture, GUI is the pop culture, and the internet is globalization. Windows eventually took over and became more accessible over time with its killer GUI apps. For the time being, Unix lacks the ecosystem to build killer GUI apps, so they created Wine to run Windows apps. There are also plenty of native Unix GUI apps that sprang up, but most are created in response to their existing commercial counterparts, and many of their GUIs are imitations. FreeBSD has been around for a while, went through several regime changes, and is still kinda authoritarian with its userland programs. Ubuntu is later to the game, has the most success in adapting to modern GUI needs, but there's still some distance to go to catch up to Apple and perhaps Windows. Even though Unix is weak in GUI stuff, it's strong as servers, especially since the internet became popular.

Sorry about the silly analogy, perhaps I need to take a nap. :)

Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by Tichy on Thursday July 23, 2009 @07:42PM (#720612)
My favorite notebook maker used to be Samsung (Korean I think), but unfortunately their latest line also has the piano lacquer problem.

Also, all the makers have far too many options to choose from.

Both seem like solvable problems to me, but perhaps they are doing well enough as it is?

Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by r7000 on Thursday July 23, 2009 @04:10PM (#720248)
Klavierlack is "piano lacquer". You see that in some high-end automotive advertising.. "black piano lacquer wood trim".
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by gamble on Thursday July 23, 2009 @04:33PM (#720297)
Sony makes decent high-end hardware... and then cripples it with loads of pre-installed crapware.
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by cstejerean on Thursday July 23, 2009 @05:31PM (#720413)
I generally buy Mac laptops and build my desktop machines, but at the right price-to-hardware ratio I wouldn't mind buying a machine with Vista and pre-installed crapware, I would wipe it as soon as I got it.
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by gamble on Thursday July 23, 2009 @05:35PM (#720422)
Assuming you wanted to be legal, you'd either need to spend a lot of time extracting the crapware, or have another Windows license kicking around. Most restore disks reinstall the crapware.
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by Tichy on Thursday July 23, 2009 @07:44PM (#720614)
Another plus for Dell. Unfortunately they don't tend to have the most elegant notebooks.
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by rms on Friday July 24, 2009 @06:32AM (#721237)
What's the best thing to do to make a high end PC look good? Make it out of carbon fiber?
Re:Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer by Tichy on Friday July 24, 2009 @07:20AM (#721262)
A lot of them looked fine before the piano lacquer abomination. Aluminum is classic, but other variants where OK, too (why not carbon fiber?). I guess there is also experimentation.

Also go for simplicity, I suppose. No fake parts designed to look "high end" in a phony way (kind of like "spoilers" on cars).

To me the utmost example of bad taste is the leather coating ASUS is going for in their latest creations. But then I don't like leather in general.

Just try to remove as many superfluous parts and elements as possible I guess. Just as Apple does - battery covers are superfluous. Mouse buttons are superfluous. Multimedia buttons are superfluous. Shiny areas anywhere but on the display are superfluous. And so on...

Important: large borders around the screen are superfluous and look cheap.

I can't think of a situation where multiple colors would look good (ie notebook cover red, bottom black), but I am not a designer.